Mass Effect 2! I think!

Mass Effect 2 is so much bigger and has the chance to be truly epic but the size can also become a weakness; there's more room for flaws.
I really can't decide which one will get the highest ranking but I think its fair to assume that both will beat the scores of the prequels.
The big difference for me though is that I know for a fact that I'll be playing ME2 but I don't know whether I want to play GOWIII since I generally find 3rd person action games really boring no matter how fast paced they are.
I don't know why but I never liked them, GOW, Ninja Gaiden, Heavenly Sword, Devil May Cry are all tedious games to me so they're obviously meant for someone else.

God of War 3 - 94

Mass Effect 2 - 93


Predicted this a while back for both titles.

woah, well thats why theres a such word like opinion lol

waoh its a close match up...lets see what will happen when more pple vote!!

I agree with the overwhelming sentiment of the forum... I think GoW3 will score a higher metacritic score, but I for one am far more hyped for Mass Effect 3, and think it will be the better game.

An awkward comparison being two such extremely different games. Personally I'm not interested in either of them.

Has to be Mass Effect 2 for me. As much as I love God of War and god killing with Kratos, I just loved Mass Effect and pretty much all Bioware RPGs.