By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - RPGFan: FFXIII Import Review(First metacritc review)

darthdevidem01 said:

The Verdict

I've beaten all of the other Final Fantasy games save XI, and XIII is one of the better single playthroughs of the bunch. Its major flaw was obvious once the credits rolled: Aside from tooling around with a few more missions, I had no reason not to shelf the game indefinitely. Maybe that's not a new thing for Final Fantasy, given that the series isn't exactly renowned for its non-linearity or replayability. Still, it is likely to disappoint folks who bought a PS3 purely for FFXIII (assuming the XBox 360 port didn't already have them crying into their pillows at night) as it falls short of being the system-selling game that FFVII was for Playstation and FFX was for PS2.

A final, hopefully illustrative comparison: FFXIII is sort of like that really hot chick with the amazing body who may be fun to hang around but doesn't grow on you that much. Infinite Space, 2009's best original RPG by my count, is like the awkward girl with the thick glasses and bad skin. She's got a chip on her shoulder and you have to get over your initial impression, but once you do, you realize that she's the coolest and most interesting person you've ever met, and ultimately she becomes not just a potential conquest but a lifelong friend. I don't mind FPS games that fall into the former category, but for RPGs, well, call it a fetish, but I'll take the lovable crater-face every time.

In spite of packing the series' best battle system, in spite of Pixar-level graphics, in spite of an Oscar worthy soundtrack, FFXIII lacks depth. It's sad to have to say that about a game that is superlative in so many ways. Strip away all of the amazing visuals and music and you have a 7, 7.5 game that scrapes by on the virtues of its combat.

Still, FFXIII is a landmark game if only by virtue of its production. Square Enix has raised the bar not simply for JRPGs, but all seventh generation games to come. It's a must-own for series fans and a must-see for just about everyone else. Here's hoping for some meaty DLC or a stronger showing from Versus XIII.

____________________________

Their other scores for FF's (these are DOMESTIC reviews not import review likt he FF13 one):

FFVII -- 90%

FFVIII -- 95%

FFIX -- 92%

FFX -- 93%

FFX-2 -- 72%

FFXII -- 97%

This review WILL NOT GO ON metacritic as its an Import Review (see review & then go to section of PS3 import reviews....these don't go on metacritic)

They might end up giving it a worse score because of the english dub.



Around the Network
Lurker said:
darthdevidem01 said:

The Verdict

I've beaten all of the other Final Fantasy games save XI, and XIII is one of the better single playthroughs of the bunch. Its major flaw was obvious once the credits rolled: Aside from tooling around with a few more missions, I had no reason not to shelf the game indefinitely. Maybe that's not a new thing for Final Fantasy, given that the series isn't exactly renowned for its non-linearity or replayability. Still, it is likely to disappoint folks who bought a PS3 purely for FFXIII (assuming the XBox 360 port didn't already have them crying into their pillows at night) as it falls short of being the system-selling game that FFVII was for Playstation and FFX was for PS2.

A final, hopefully illustrative comparison: FFXIII is sort of like that really hot chick with the amazing body who may be fun to hang around but doesn't grow on you that much. Infinite Space, 2009's best original RPG by my count, is like the awkward girl with the thick glasses and bad skin. She's got a chip on her shoulder and you have to get over your initial impression, but once you do, you realize that she's the coolest and most interesting person you've ever met, and ultimately she becomes not just a potential conquest but a lifelong friend. I don't mind FPS games that fall into the former category, but for RPGs, well, call it a fetish, but I'll take the lovable crater-face every time.

In spite of packing the series' best battle system, in spite of Pixar-level graphics, in spite of an Oscar worthy soundtrack, FFXIII lacks depth. It's sad to have to say that about a game that is superlative in so many ways. Strip away all of the amazing visuals and music and you have a 7, 7.5 game that scrapes by on the virtues of its combat.

Still, FFXIII is a landmark game if only by virtue of its production. Square Enix has raised the bar not simply for JRPGs, but all seventh generation games to come. It's a must-own for series fans and a must-see for just about everyone else. Here's hoping for some meaty DLC or a stronger showing from Versus XIII.

____________________________

Their other scores for FF's (these are DOMESTIC reviews not import review likt he FF13 one):

FFVII -- 90%

FFVIII -- 95%

FFIX -- 92%

FFX -- 93%

FFX-2 -- 72%

FFXII -- 97%

This review WILL NOT GO ON metacritic as its an Import Review (see review & then go to section of PS3 import reviews....these don't go on metacritic)

They might end up giving it a worse score because of the english dub.

it can go either way, also depends on which reviewer plays it too. many factors are involved. If he dub is like FF12 though, they will have no complaints



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

can't wait to buy it as well



Am I really dumb at math or there are some errors with those numbers. We have

Graphics: 99%

Sound: 99%

Gameplay: 80%

Control: 85%

Story: 90%

When I sum everything it gives me: 453/500 so it's an average of 90.6%.



riecsou said:
Am I really dumb at math or there are some errors with those numbers. We have

Graphics: 99%

Sound: 99%

Gameplay: 80%

Control: 85%

Story: 90%

When I sum everything it gives me: 453/500 so it's an average of 90.6%.

Nah it's obvious that they don't make an average score as most (dare I say all ?) reviewers.

Gameplay is the most important part of a game and that's why it did not get a 90+ score.



Around the Network
Barozi said:
riecsou said:
Am I really dumb at math or there are some errors with those numbers. We have

Graphics: 99%

Sound: 99%

Gameplay: 80%

Control: 85%

Story: 90%

When I sum everything it gives me: 453/500 so it's an average of 90.6%.

Nah it's obvious that they don't make an average score as most (dare I say all ?) reviewers.

Gameplay is the most important part of a game and that's why it did not get a 90+ score.

which is odd as the vast majority claim the gameplay is the best part....huh



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

Meh, unimpressive.



Lets wait for reviews from people that don't compare games to girls they'd like to sleep with...



I'm a mod, come to me if there's mod'n to do. 

Chrizum is the best thing to happen to the internet, Period.

Serves me right for challenging his sales predictions!

Bet with dsisister44: Red Steel 2 will sell 1 million within it's first 365 days of sales.

darthdevidem01 said:
Barozi said:
riecsou said:
Am I really dumb at math or there are some errors with those numbers. We have

Graphics: 99%

Sound: 99%

Gameplay: 80%

Control: 85%

Story: 90%

When I sum everything it gives me: 453/500 so it's an average of 90.6%.

Nah it's obvious that they don't make an average score as most (dare I say all ?) reviewers.

Gameplay is the most important part of a game and that's why it did not get a 90+ score.

which is odd as the vast majority claim the gameplay is the best part....huh


I think you might have confused combat with gameplay. In which case I haven't heard anything positive about either...besides that it might provide some challenge.



 

libellule said:
--OkeyDokey-- said:
Still waiting for a AAA JRPG 4 years into the gen ;_;

Demon Soul ?

other than this ... I dont see

Demon's Souls is not AAA based on metacritic:

http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/ps3/demonssouls?q=demon%27s%20souls