OT: Demon's Souls. Because I like it more than UnchartedTwo, if I say inFamous not enough people will agree with me, and after my experience with CoD4, there's no way I'll pay for MW2. The game was fun at first but later on it just felt annoying...  

yes i played it and returned it.its overhyped overrated and overpriced.

SP = UC2 (havnt played either so idk really)

MP = MW2

Coop= L4D2

thats pretty much the same reaction everyone had after playing Uncharted 2. it pretty much KILLED the hype for MW2 and after suffering the horrible campaign mode i can see why.

UC 2 if we speak the truth im tired of FPS but if goty depends of hype than MW2

it always does sadly

No offence but this thread will probably turn in to a war, almost all ps3 fans will say Uncharted 2 others will say that just because Uncharted 2 ps3 exclusive.

Uncharted 2 wins for graphics and single player campaign

Modern Warfare 2 wins for online multiplayer/value


Overall I'd say MW2 wins by a hair.

well actually Tbone, when it comes to software fan-boys are less AGGRESSIVE. especially when the software uncharted 2 doesn't have a similar version on the other system. I think if you ask all the 360 fans here (the smart) most of them will say uncharted 2 is one of the best of this gen. (the ones that played it)

Uncharted 2 has set new standards for story and graphics. The fact that we are discussing this topic is plain ridiculous.