Ahh... yes, continuing the tradition of great FF music. Although some of those older songs really make me feel nostalgic for those games.
-dunno001
-On a quest for the truly perfect game; I don't think it exists...
Ahh... yes, continuing the tradition of great FF music. Although some of those older songs really make me feel nostalgic for those games.
-dunno001
-On a quest for the truly perfect game; I don't think it exists...
pastro243 said:
Reality is that melodies and harmonies in a song make it richer, and I can find both in these. The chocobo theme didnt sound like elevator music and saying the other songs are "meh" or typical orchestrated music is like when people that listen to britney spears say every metal song sounds the same, a guitar and a guy hitting the drums fast. |
I will admit these pieces are not "bad". It is merely the general stylistic trend that I lament. For example, you say you found a melody in the first section of the second theme, but I very much doubt that considering it is just a chord progression. The second section is much better, but the lack of melodic development (the melody only plays once and has little to no recurring motifs) means I'm probably not going to remember it very well.
Do you disagree? Perhaps my musical ear and palette simply aren't as refined as yours, but I still know I would prefer something by, say, Yasunori Mitsuda or James Horner (not Titanic).
Helios said:
I will admit these pieces are not "bad". It is merely the general stylistic trend that I lament. For example, you say you found a melody in the first section of the second theme, but I very much doubt that considering it is just a chord progression. The second section is much better, but the lack of melodic development (the melody only plays once and has little to no recurring motifs) means I'm probably not going to remember it very well. Do you disagree? Perhaps my musical ear and palette simply aren't as refined as yours, but I still know I would prefer something by, say, Yasunori Mitsuda or James Horner (not Titanic). |
I understand what you say, the impact that the game music will have on us we will have to see when we get the game, but saying the tracks are bad and generic(when almost every orchestral track may sound generic at frst listen) is something I wouldnt do.
You have to remember these tracks will be repeating itselves many times(in a menu, a fight, etc...) so a evolution in the song may not be the best thing here when you consider this, opossed to a movie where you know the music will appear in a climax or an action that will make the music tracks "evolve" according to this. Unless, they can create something like Shadow of the Colossus, but the nature of the game wont let them.
The real good thing in which we will apreciate how good this game music will be is in the main theme or the one that will appear in the credits or cineematic secuences. That just reffering to music as it is and not as soundtrack to the gameplay, which I think RPGs lack of substance compared to a game like shadow of the colossus in which the gameplay moves the music. I dont think its a bad thing but its just the way it is.
- Our album on spotify https://open.spotify.com/album/56mEbEgyBYGzcDyZ1eMQ1v?si=hYKgir5YRSCrzywgGmV4oQ
- Our videoclip
- My manga: https://www.webtoons.com/en/challenge/blanca-the-world/list?title_no=313068
Alic0004 said: Wow, impressive how inventive this composer is... what's his name? It almost doesn't sound like game music, he's really pushing how much can be going on in the music.
|
Couldnt't have said it better myself.
This is the true definition of owning.