9.3

+ already mentioned in the thread

- Linear. Enemies re-spawn too much.

8.0

+ Good athmosphere
- Bad character/monster designs

9.5

+ Fantastic atmosphere and presentation; interesting plot concepts.
+ Variety of weapons and plasmids to play with; different combinations play very differently.
+ Big Daddies are one of the best character designs this gen.
- Gameplay becomes repetitive before the end.

10

There are quite a few games that I like more that I would rate lower, but if any game this gen actually deserved a perfect score, I think this might be it. It is unique, beautiful, scary, twisted, brilliant, stunning, fun, imaginative, well I could go on and on. The only negative I could really throw it's way is a lackluster ending. But in the grand scheme of things, it doesn't matter, because you'll probably find yourself replaying the game as soon as you beat it regardless.

9.8
Great setting and story. Graphics are great + the art direction is the best i have ever seen in a game.
Gameplaywise, it might seem too easy at some points.

8.5

Pros:
Good story up to a point
Atmosphere
Graphics, especially of the water at the time
Some cool plasmids

Cons:
Moral choice was made a bit redundant by the fact you never see the consequences of harvesting a little sister
Endings are crap
No multiplayer
Minigames/puzzles were a bit annoying after a while
Feels like a step down from System shock 2 and Deus Ex

Whoot ? O_o

Bioshock 9.2-3

Good: The best atmosphere of any game ever. Good story, graphics, setting, and combat. And Sander fuckin' Cohen.
Bad: final boss battle was bit of a letdown, some bugs and graphical hick ups.
Ugly: ps3 exclusive content, yuck.

7.9/10

Bioshock is build to be a movie. I'm sure it will be an awesome movie (a lot better than the game)

+ Great atmosphere

- Graphics are really bizarre. I know they're not that bad but I think it looks very ugly in motion.
- Horrible controls
- Very repetitive environnement
- It's just not fun to play.

6
I found it to be overhyped.