I seem to never agree with GI though on their ninty reviews.

They don't seem to even agree with themselves.

Their opinions seem to differ.

One of the bigger disparities Ive seen in their review for this magazine.Wait for other reviews to see if this a start of a trend for this game.

Those two reviews are not really contradictory.

Take them together, and the conclusion is that this is a good on-rails shooter, but not what would be expected from the Dead Space franchise.

great rent game :)

By the way, I think it's quite possible this game fails, given that the on-rails genre is already well represented on the Wii.

Unless this gets great reviews and lots of marketing, I don't see why a big number of Wii users would be drawn in.

Looks like Game Informer had to do a bad review in order to offset their good review. We know how much they love the Wii.

That being said, I think that there are plenty of light gun shooters on the Wii and it will take a lot for a new one to stand out from the others. Hopefully, this is that kind of game.

Why on-rails?

this shows why reviews make so little sense