no it wouldn't be because Fisher would have already sabotaged the thing and it would blow up in a mess... People seem to forget that Fisher not only has more training he's also got the better hand to hand combat... in stealth Sam wins... in face to face Sam wins... the great equalizer? Guns

More training than Solid Snake?

The guy was created to be the perfect soldier and has MASTERED CQC

Stealth? Octo-camo...

Solid Eye > The 3 green lights

Snake also wins hands down in weapons.

When Sam Fisher has been through even HALF of what Solid Snake has been through... then they should be compared seriously.

I'd go Snake.

Batman beats them both at once.

You know... CQC is roughly analogous to the Israeli hand to hand training...

CQC is a kind of Martial arts Marines used to be taught.

It's pretty effective style of hand to hand combat, but it's nowhere on the same level as what is taught to Delta Force or special forces in Israel.  The shit Fisher uses is insanely useful in face to face encounters like what may occur in infiltration missions.  Lets not forget Sam doesn't have a crazy genetic desease either and this man has been through some crazy shit... if you understood the kind of shit that the groups he was in did you wouldn't underestimate him so much.  The only way Snake wins is in a firefight and even then that just equalizes things out.

Oh boy, I wonder who is gonna win this?

I'm not surprised to see this thread was brought to us by CGI-Quality. A subtle PS3 exclusive vs 360 exclusive.

Sam is a pro, but he's just not Tiger Woods, if you get my meaning.

Snake would win.

snake anyday,even if he gets killed the sound of otacon going snaaaaaaake would kill him anyway

Can we have Batman vs. Snake next? Batman would own bitches, damnit!

sam wins b/c master chief already kill snake in a thread