insomniac17 said:
Kantor said:
insomniac17 said:
Kantor said:
insomniac17 said:
Kantor said: Everyone saying "no" to number 10, I doubt you would feel the same after five SECONDS of torment, let alone an eternity. |
Or we're just not assholes/we are Christian. I'm working hard at not ending up there since, as a Christian, I do believe there is a Hell, and I know that I don't want to spend the rest of forever there. If I do end up there though, why would I want to make other people suffer because of my mistakes?
EDIT: Random thought; I wonder what DMJ would think of the kitten one...
|
Here's a simpler one: If you could kill a person you've never met to save your own life, would you?
|
No. Would you?
|
Either you're a better person than me, or a better liar. I would.
|
No, I'm not a liar. I'd feel terrible knowing that there's a good chance the person I killed would have had a family/people who cared for him/her, and I couldn't live with myself. The only way I can imagine myself killing someone is in self defence or if they manage to make me so angry that I snap (which would take a lot). Even then, I'd still feel bad about it. I guess I'm just not a killer.
|
I would also feel terrible in the situation you described, but I would feel considerably worse if I was dead. I'm not a killer, either. The thought of killing somebody makes me feel sick. But if it was to save my life, or the life of somebody I was very close to, I would definitely consider it.
What if we changed it a little, and said you had to kill this person to save the life of your best friend?
Though having said that, your argument about the person you kill having people care about him/her, surely there are people who care about you who would be equally devastated if you died?
It's a bit like another conundrum I heard. A train is travelling on a track. Four people are tied to the track. If you do nothing, they will all die. You can pull a lever to make the train change tracks. One person is lying on this second track. If you do so, the one will die, but the four will survive. Would you pull the lever? I certainly would, it's three fewer deaths. But some people, apparently, think that pulling the lever is murder, and leaving the four to die isn't. What's your opinion on that?