Doctor yes; Cop maybe not, since he can get the doctor's protection, and killing him off validates his investigation results.

I agree that the other way didn't work, but I'm not 100% sure your suggestion is fullproof. Then again, what's the worst that could happen? You lose an internet game. The world won't end. Maybe we should try it, but it is a big leap of trust. What does everyone think?

I think we take the chance. I'm not either by the way. I'm vanilla townsfolk.

How do we know someone isn't lying about being a cop or doctor?

There's no way, you gotta analyze what someone says and decide to trust him or not. It may take the round after to see whether someone was lying or not when he said he was cop/doctor but, other than that, there's no other way other than your instinct

Votes so far (Day 1)

wow nice table.

Anyways, I'm finally here ^_^

Remember what happened last game?

The problem I see, Zexen, is if we mislynch, then we'll have 5 townies + 3 mafia. Night will come, and of course scum will not kill other scum, so automatically another townie will go down.

So by the second day, you have 4 townies vs. 3 mafia. if we make just ONE mistake on day two, the mafia will of course vote as a block to make a majority and end the game on a mislynch.  Remember that in the event where there mafia make up 50% of more, they win, since no majority can be made. We need to be REALLY careful this time.

Also remember I was the cop last game and was COMPLETELY thrown off when people started bandwagoning and voting randomly in the first round. I ended up investigating townies because they acted suspiciously. Lets try to at least have some basis for voting, as opposed to voting randomly.

Good luck with that. No one is going to vote, or even post in the first day because no one wants to seem suspicious in fear of lynching. Unless you have a good idea for weeding out the Mafia on day one, we're just going to sit here and stare at each other, wondering.

well ok fine. All we have to go on is from last, which really isn't saying much.

Remember that Onyxmeth was a mafia, and ON TOP OF THAT, he was a whore, so when he found out I was the cop, he messed up my investigation and Soleron told me that C03 was innocent, even though he was actually scum.

So lets not rule out the possibility of another whore and/or any other secret roles for this second game.

Right now, I have the FINGER OF SUSPICION on Soleron and Onyxmeth. Being that he WAS the whore last game, he knows very well that if the cop roleclaims himself early, he wouldn't NEED to be killed, as the whore would just be all over him like.... well... a whore.

Onyxmeth also insisted on claiming himself to be a townie twice now, even though there were not accusations against him.

Both were suggesting for the cop to roleclaim early, so he can gain protection from the doctor. And if there's a whore, then the cop's mis-investigations can ruin the game.