Maybe not 10. The chances of that are low for any game. But a really high 9 is realistic. Gow and SotC both scored 9.7-9.8 last gen and were new IPs. LBP scored a 9.7. Jak 3 last gen scored a 9.6...

U2 will probably be in that high 9.6-9.9 range. Especially considering the first one got a 9.1 from IGN and the sequel has improved in every way possible.

IGN - 92
GS - 90

9.4 from IGN
9.0 from Gamespot.
91 Metacritic.

IGN 93

GS 90

SDF 12/10 :P

9.0 Ign

7.9 Gs

LOL...wow...really? A whole .1 increase from IGN over it's predeccesor, even though it has major improvements in every possible area.

You're so generous!

Uncharted 1 got a 9.1 from IGN.

What makes you think Uncharted 2 will get a lower score when it's been improved so much?

7.9 at GS? GameSpot doesnt rate games like that any more, and havent for awhile. It would either be a 7.5 or 8.0 or 8.5 or 9.0 or 9.5, etc. Get it?

LOL...this forum is a joke. I wonder if the people here put any thought into their posts at all.

GS 9.5 l.o.f
IGN 9 or higher

Do you go out of your way to act like a jerk?

With every improvement to a sequel comes the chance it will break something else gameplay wise, it's not automatic that improvements will be appreciated.  Then there is the fact that when the original was released there was a lot less games available at the time, when you rate games you take into account the competition in your rating too.    I merely stated what I thought they would give for the game given the stuff I've seen of the game, stop acting like an idiot stating peoples opinions are wrong, you just look like a complete moron.

9.6 or something ridiculously high from IGN. 9.0 from Gamespot.