The "No trophies" dosent really justify the game not deserving GotY... spec when the ps3 version of the game is "supposedly" far worse than the PC/360 versions. as for the rest of your arguements... none of them really make sence, the graphics imo are ace. maybe your missing the colours and green-ness... its a post-nuclear war landscape... there will be no vibrancy (unless you go to "oasis") The blood IS there... you said you didnt see blood when you killed a bug... an effing BUG!!! with a BB GUN!!!
and wait... you said you had the special edition box? does that mean you expected the graphics to be cartoony? your logic keeps failing over and over again. please stop. your huting my feelings now

i didn' say Fallout 3 shouldn't be game of the year i said i hate that game.

''spec when the ps3 version of the game is "supposedly" far worse than the PC/360 versions''

as i said i hate fallout 3 so i don't care.

And i killed the bug with the normal gun with bullets.i even killed some enemies with grenades and there were no blood.

and i don't expect graphics to be cartooney, graphics are just one small bad part of this game. I EXPECTED SOME TROPHIES!!! For example: you bought the game who SUPOSED to have dragons, but when you played it you didn't find any dragons there. would you be dissapoitment? That's why i am mad. they screwed me over. all those other reasons may not be so important, but paying extra for less? and stop replaying to me, everybody has right to have opinnion.

You think Fallout is good? OK

I think Fallout is bad? OK

Meh. im past this now... everybody has there opinion. its just yours is wrong

Carl2291 said: Meh. im past this now... everybody has there opinion. its just yours is wrong

 i could say the same for yours since we have diffrent opinnion

Because IGN's only good reviewers are the Sony ones. Hence the fact that every single one of the PS3 awards is well chosen (except voice acting and story, but hey, they felt sorry for GTA4).

I imagine it went something like this:

2005:

PS2 team: GOD OF WAR!

XB team: Well I think-

PS2 team: God...of...war...

XB Team: Yes, sir. Sorry sir.

2008:

PS3 team: MGS4!

360 team: Hell no!

PS3 team: m...g...s...4...

360 team: That doesn't work any more, our console has outsold yours!

PS3 team: Damn.

Wii team: I think-

360 team: Go away.

@ snake... your logic is once again flawed as i am never ever wrong. tbh... im just amazing

@ kantor - "Wii team: I think-

360 team: Go away."

Lmao thanks, now i get it XD.

Alright the J man is going to say it. IGN made an excellent choice by picking fallout 3 and it deserved it more than lbp and mgs 4 /thread

I agree, Fallout 3 was awesome.

YAY! It's my favorite game of this generation, I think it's the best RPG ever; good choice, IGN! ;)