... wat

I would say Tetris or Pacman.
But then I'm strange.

World of Warcraft... the whole series did pretty well every where

No Gran Tourismo?

Gran Turismo 3: A-Spec:

Region Japan America Others Total
Total Sales 1.89m 7.13m 5.85m 14.87m

Final Fantasy VII:

Region Japan America Others Total
Total Sales 3.93m 3.09m 2.70m 9.72m

That's not worldwide appeal?

Gran Turismo, Final Fantasy, MGS

and Crash 3 nearly has WW apeal

Total Sales 1.45m 3.76m 1.91m 7.12m

If you disagree with MGS 4, then look at its sales

Total Sales 0.66m 1.51m 1.61m 3.78m

JP is only so small because the PS3 is not doing very well in Japan

Personally, I'd say that that proves that it's had worldwide appeal. When checking if they actually have worldwide appeal now, we'd have to wait for GT5 and FFXIII. Not that I doubt they still do, just saying.

What about SSB? Wii series?

It looks like you're going for games with similar sales in all three "regions," but calling that worldwide appeal wouldn't make sense to me. Japan is a much smaller market than America/Others, so if a game sells anywhere close to as many copies there as it does in the west, it appeals more to the Japanese than anywhere else (see Final Fantasy, Pokemon, 2D Mario, NDS, etc).

It still appeals WW, just more to the Japanese market