Twilight Princess. I liked the art direction better. WW was a very fun game though also.

No challenge is the case for all the Zelda 3Ds I am afraid. I recently did a replay of both OoT and Majora's Mask (been a few years since the last time) and I wasn't close to dying even once.

First time I played Twilight Princess I died once, when the first twilight portal opened and the three (maybe it was two) monsters fell out and I only had 3 hearts (before Midna told me to hold "B" they had already taken 2.5 of my hearts). Only hard part of Twilight Princess is the Fairy Dungeon thing with a gazillion levels, apart from that no challenge. Only difference between Wind Waker and the others is that instead of maybe being down to 1/3rd of your life on the worst in the others in Wind Waker you would rarely get to 50%. But dying, no.

Exception might be the Water Temple boss in Majora's Mask if you mess up and don't have enough potions/fairies.

Zelda hasn't been hard since Zelda II on NES. THAT is hard.

Twilight Princess, I suppose.

The next Zelda that I want to play is The Minish Cap, because in the Zelda Retrospective over at Game Trailers they say that The Minish Cap is chronologically the first Zelda game as it deals with The Legend of Gustave. The Last Zelda game I played to completion was Ocarina of Time back in 2002. I would have played The Windwaker to completion, but I've never had enough money at one particular point in time to get a link cable and Zelda: A Link to the Past for GBA, and I feel that I wouldn't want to complete it without all the bells and whistles that brings to it, so I've only played Wind Waker to the point where Link joins the pirate crew and they leave the initial island before thinking I couldn't go on without also having the Tingle Parts.  It remains one of my biggest gaming dreams to play all the games in this series back to back and in proper order.

Has anyone else here watched the Game Trailer's Zelda Retrospective:

(http://www.gametrailers.com/game/5269.html

Part 6 http://www.gametrailers.com/player/15194.html

gives the chronology and the two paths theory.)

and played Twilight Princess? Their retrospective ends before the release of Phantom Hourglass and Twilight Princess. I'm assuming Phantom Hourglass directly follows WindWaker, but I am wondering if anyone knows where Twilight Princess fits in and if they could say without spoilers. Does Twilight Princess really take place in Hyrule B before Windwaker as proposed by Game Trailers?  They weren't certain because they hadn't played the game before their Retrospective was posted.

So you want Fable 1?  XD

what the hell is wrong with you ppl.

wind waker better than TP?

friggin never.

see here and you'll know why

http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/thread.php?id=46772&page=1

dam hypocrites....all these zelda/ninty fans claim 'it's not about the graphics' but they rate WW better because of the graphics.

screw you guys, i'm going home

i liked Twiligh better because i didn't like the cell shade graphics as much as i like the way TP looked. Bot great games though.

I agree. And I loved the sailing part too. But TP is just better if I have to choose.

I liked Wind Waker better, too. I was actually quite fond of the sailing. I loved the artstyle, the humor. I just had alot of fun playing it, it was refreshing. Even though they are similar, TP seemed more like a rehash of games past. Wind Waker just stands out, and it's not just the visuals that do it.

@soriku

aight aight

that was really the main part of the game that i gave respect for

the rest meh..

therefore i couldn't rate it above!

the wind waker, it just was way less linear and i like the cartoony style more