Nah, with that much amount in fan service in the game, a fleshed out single player experience, and oodles and oodles of replayability, I'd say that it's a game that delivered on its promises.

Well, I do have two small gripes... one would be tripping and I just wished they did more with the online aspect of the game. Maybe next time...

Oh! Knuckles and Ridley need to be in the next one.

No, one of the best. Thats why it sold over 8 million copies in nine months. Thanks for asking.

I find no difficulty understanding how someone who likes GOW would dislike SSBB and not understand or appreciate it. I feel exactly the same way, only in reverse.

Brawl is not overrated.

I would actually call the whole Smash Bros. series underrated. They really changed the whole fighter formula, and for the better. I personally find them so much more fun than the traditional fighter.

If it wasn't for Smash, I would have quit fighting games after Street Fighter 2.

 100% Agree with this.

okay i hate nintendo, and think its kind of over-rated...but most over-rated all time? hell no

I find super smash quite innovative and underrated, really.

Overhyped? Yes. For so many reasons. 60 character roster expected, characters that wasn't obviously gonna be playable were expected too. (Who the fuck thought Cloud had a chance in the first place? I don't mean any disrespect for the character but seriously...) etc etc

Overrated? Definitely no. You'd be even laughed at for liking Brawl, and I've seen it happened everywhere :|

The game deserves the high ratings. I waited to get my reserved copy from 9:15 PM until it opened, in the cold, while sick, to get the game as fast as possible. It was so worth it and I had a lot of fun, and still play it sometimes :)

Dead or Alive is Overrated, Not SSBB.