Is Super Smash Bros Brawl the most overrated fighting game of all time?

[Grampy]

bouzane said:

11ht11 said:

bouzane said:
I'd go as far as to say that Brawl is one of the most overrated games of all time regardless of genre. I think that if you removed the Nintendo characters and replaced them with stick figures the sales would drop by 95% and the review scores would drop below 80%. I just don't understand the appeal of the franchise at all, but then again, I never really liked beat 'em up games all that much.

 LOL!!!!!

 EDIT: id would say that if GOW was NOT a sony franchise you probably wouldnt care about it as much

I don't like Sony and I criticize them often. I also dislike the PS3 and I criticize it often. My enjoyment of GoW has nothing to do with brand name and everything to do with the highly enjoyable combat.

I find no difficulty understanding how someone who likes GOW would dislike SSBB and not understand or appreciate it. I feel exactly the same way, only in reverse.