By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Resistance 2 metacritic

what do you think the metacritic rating for resistance 2 will be at the end



Around the Network

well its at 88 so I would say around 89, MAYBE (big maybe) 90. Variety just gave it a 70 (whoever they are) which lowered it to an 88. It's weird, I clicked on their review, and didnt find a number at all, yea it was negative, but still, no number. Is Metacritic making up numbers?



SnakeEyez said:
well its at 88 so I would say around 89, MAYBE (big maybe) 90. Variety just gave it a 70 (whoever they are) which lowered it to an 88. It's weird, I clicked on their review, and didnt find a number at all, yea it was negative, but still, no number. Is Metacritic making up numbers?

'Variety' is a relatively new games reviewer metacritic have added.

 

They gave LittleBigPlanet it's lowest review score: an 80. (15 points below average)

And now Resistance 2 it's lowest score: a 70 (18 points below average)

Sheesh.

Then the gave Fable II a 9.8 (8 points above the average)

and Fallout 3 a 9.7 (4 points above average)

They've only given a few reviews, but already their reviews seem to deviate quite a bit from more mainstream media outlets.

 

Edit: They also don't apparently give scores on their site, instead their editor just tells metacritic the score.



 

Xplay gave it a 5/5



Variety is a joke.

If a site has no score, they simply should not count.



iPhone = Great gaming device. Don't agree? Who cares, because you're wrong.

Currently playing:

Final Fantasy VI (iOS), Final Fantasy: Record Keeper (iOS) & Dragon Quest V (iOS)     

    

Got a retro room? Post it here!

Around the Network
Euphoria14 said:
Variety is a joke.

If a site has no score, they simply should not count.

Actually they person who runs variety gives the score to metacritic, but variety themselves seem fanboyish.

 



 

Dallinor said:
SnakeEyez said:
well its at 88 so I would say around 89, MAYBE (big maybe) 90. Variety just gave it a 70 (whoever they are) which lowered it to an 88. It's weird, I clicked on their review, and didnt find a number at all, yea it was negative, but still, no number. Is Metacritic making up numbers?

'Variety' is a relatively new games reviewer metacritic have added.

 

They gave LittleBigPlanet it's lowest review score: an 80. (15 points below average)

And now Resistance 2 it's lowest score: a 70 (18 points below average)

Sheesh.

Then the gave Fable II a 9.8 (8 points above the average)

and Fallout 3 a 9.7 (4 points above average)

They've only given a few reviews, but already their reviews seem to deviate quite a bit from more mainstream media outlets.

 

Edit: They also don't apparently give scores on their site, instead their editor just tells metacritic the score.

 

So is this wat 1up does with metacritic as well? They gave R2 a B+ and Metacritic has that as a 83 (5 points or so from what a B+ really is) and yet they gave Gears 2 an A and Metacritic has that as a 100. I don't think a logical person would think that there is a 17 point difference between a B+ and an A.



SnakeEyez said:
Dallinor said:
SnakeEyez said:
well its at 88 so I would say around 89, MAYBE (big maybe) 90. Variety just gave it a 70 (whoever they are) which lowered it to an 88. It's weird, I clicked on their review, and didnt find a number at all, yea it was negative, but still, no number. Is Metacritic making up numbers?

'Variety' is a relatively new games reviewer metacritic have added.

 

They gave LittleBigPlanet it's lowest review score: an 80. (15 points below average)

And now Resistance 2 it's lowest score: a 70 (18 points below average)

Sheesh.

Then the gave Fable II a 9.8 (8 points above the average)

and Fallout 3 a 9.7 (4 points above average)

They've only given a few reviews, but already their reviews seem to deviate quite a bit from more mainstream media outlets.

 

Edit: They also don't apparently give scores on their site, instead their editor just tells metacritic the score.

 

So is this wat 1up does with metacritic as well? They gave R2 a B+ and Metacritic has that as a 83 (5 points or so from what a B+ really is) and yet they gave Gears 2 an A and Metacritic has that as a 100. I don't think a logical person would think that there is a 17 point difference between a B+ and an A.

 

We are not 100% sure on what metacritic does with 1up, but they are  hated now by the ps3 fans so what does it matter. Oh and IGN is the site to go now.

I honestly miss the days when ps3 owners never cared about review scores.



 

Euphoria14 said:
Variety is a joke.

If a site has no score, they simply should not count.

 

I wouldn't be so quick to call Variety a joke.  I don't know about their reviews but they have some good stuff and some good sources.



Resistance 2 should end up somewhere between 87 to 91.

There scores are not an straight average, as some sites are weighted more than others. The 70% from Variety might not be contributing much to the overall score.