By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony Discussion - Best of E3 awards, Best of Show : X Play.

evilman279 on 18 July 2008
Kasz216 said:
evilman279 said:
Kasz216 said:
evilman279 said:
Kasz216 said:
evilman279 said:
Kasz216 said:
evilman279 said:
Kasz216 said:
evilman279 said:
Kasz216 said:
evilman279 said:
shio said:
Is that even the official E3 Awards? I'm surprised they didn't even mention Spore.

Spore >>> LBP

 

im sorry, but in spore all you get to do is create your monster thats it. in LBP you create THE ENTIRE GAME, you create the level, boss fights, enemies, your own character. im sure spore has lots and lots of possibilites, but little big planet is litmit less, that game is never ending, and the innovation in that game is absolutely amazing, i wouldnt be surprised if it got game of the year, there is nothing like it, it completely created its own genre and nothing even gets close, that game user created content to the MAX.

Actually there are plenty of games like LBP on the computer.

 

you sure? name me those games. dont name games that you can mod. give me a game that you can make that entire game as you wish

 

For one.

http://www.clickteam.com/eng/tgf2.php

It lets you do a LOT more then LBP does actually. You can make a lot more then just basic platformers.

awesome, now, can you show me a game that runs at 720p and upscaled to 1080p and you can do the same thing, plus in LBP you can create you own story line

 

You can create your own story in that too... so... now your whole arguement for why it's amazing and innovative is "It's in 720P!"

Well Spore is way more innovative then just being in 720P so... arguement over?

 

 

no, is not over, because in LBP you can make the game a racer, a shooter, YOU CAN MAKE YOUR OWN STORY LINE. NOW SHOW ME A GAME THAT WAS USED AS A POWERPOINT PRESENTATION FOR THEIR E3 CONFERENCE

You could do all that with the game i showed you.... hell i've used Tiny Toons Cartoon Creator for a power point presentation.

You can make your own storyline in that game... i've done it... multiple times with one of it's predaccessors.

ok kool, now the problem with spore is, you are limited to creature creation, with LBP you literally turn it into your own game, you can make it a platformer, a racer, a shooter. can you do that with spore? i dont think so. honestly dude i think that if LBP were for the wii you would be jumping and screaming right now.

1. You aren't limited to creature creation, infact you create way more then that.

2. It's not the creation that makes it innovative. It's HOW it's created using procedural generation. LBP is archaic in comparison in it's creation methods which are basic building block methods.

3. Spore isn't at it's base a game creating game. The procedural creation is part of what makes it innovative, as is the fact that unlike LBP it actually has created it's own little genre of game because it incoporates many types of gameplay style.

Procedural character generation beats out 720P in terms of innovation.

ok then, if spore is not mainly about creating, then why say its better than LBP is you cant compare them. thats like saying gears of war two is better than mario

 

I said more innovative.  Though as for why it would be better?  Because content creation isn't the center of the game.  Games where content creation is the center of the game hardly ever work.

While spore takes your character creation and molds it around other peoples character creations.  The game is about the game more so then character creation.

It handles character creations and shapes it rather then it just being out their randomly.

EXACTLY CONTENT CREATION IS NOT THE CENTER OF SPORE, so you cant compare to little big planet, all i want to know is why did you compare little big planet and spore if according to you they arent the same type of games.

 



Around the Network
brute on 18 July 2008

LBP does look like it will be great



tag:"reviews only matter for the real hardcore gamer"

deathcape on 18 July 2008
evilman279 said:
deathcape said:
evilman279 said:
deathcape said:
lol...in LBP you CANNOT create your own character....

as for how many options you have..we don't even KNOW yet...

LBP is interesting though...just not that special

 

in little big planet you can do limitless things to your charater, you can even take a picture of your self with the ps eye, and stick it to your charater's face or shirt,

im sorry but if thats not special i really dont know what can be special for you

 

look at Spore or Portal..those are really special games

 

LBP? lol..can't create your character ....changing it..or customizing it is not creating it

 

as for the levels..the way I saw it..it has a very limited amount of options you can use....just main building block really.

 

it would be special if you could CREATE every single obstacle you wanted..... get me?

 

yes i undertand what you are saying, but, like you said, they give you the basic building tools and blocks, its up to the user to be creative and combine the tools to create something completely amazing

 

this is what's wrong..Spore does NOT give you building blocks..it gives you parts of building blocks..and that makes the creating more random..and instead of creating something once..and it's done

in spore it lives...evolves..it grows...it's something that truly intruiges me



The Truth About Nintendo

The truth about Hardcore and Casual

Kasz216 on 18 July 2008

Because when comparing innovation it doesn't matter if they are in different genres.



psrock on 18 July 2008
Kasz216 said:
Because when comparing innovation it doesn't matter if they are in different genres.

 

What makes you think it wont suck? innovation does not mean good.



 Next Gen 

11/20/09 04:25 makingmusic476 Warning Other (Your avatar is borderline NSFW. Please keep it for as long as possible.)
Around the Network
The_vagabond7 on 18 July 2008
evilman279 said:
Kasz216 said:
evilman279 said:
Kasz216 said:

 

o

I

EXACTLY CONTENT CREATION IS NOT THE CENTER OF SPORE, so you cant compare to little big planet, all i want to know is why did you compare little big planet and spore if according to you they arent the same type of games.

 

lol, he didn't compare the two. Somebody said spore should've been the game of the show, instead of LBP, you got all huffy about it, Kazs stepped in.

Calm down, and drink your kool-aid.

 



You can find me on facebook as Markus Van Rijn, if you friend me just mention you're from VGchartz and who you are here.

evilman279 on 18 July 2008
deathcape said:
evilman279 said:
deathcape said:
evilman279 said:
deathcape said:
lol...in LBP you CANNOT create your own character....

as for how many options you have..we don't even KNOW yet...

LBP is interesting though...just not that special

 

in little big planet you can do limitless things to your charater, you can even take a picture of your self with the ps eye, and stick it to your charater's face or shirt,

im sorry but if thats not special i really dont know what can be special for you

 

look at Spore or Portal..those are really special games

 

LBP? lol..can't create your character ....changing it..or customizing it is not creating it

 

as for the levels..the way I saw it..it has a very limited amount of options you can use....just main building block really.

 

it would be special if you could CREATE every single obstacle you wanted..... get me?

 

yes i undertand what you are saying, but, like you said, they give you the basic building tools and blocks, its up to the user to be creative and combine the tools to create something completely amazing

 

this is what's wrong..Spore does NOT give you building blocks..it gives you parts of building blocks..and that makes the creating more random..and instead of creating something once..and it's done

in spore it lives...evolves..it grows...it's something that truly intruiges me

yes and you are right in that aspect of having the creature grow and evolve. but LBP is just completely limitless, for example watch the video in the link below this and see what kind of things you can do with LBP and how you can create  a story from the ground up. EVERYTHING IN THAT VIDEO IS USER CREATED

http://youtube.com/watch?v=3yH26v39ZK4

 



makingmusic476 on 18 July 2008
IllegalPaladin said:

No mention of Killzone 2? I'm mentioning that because that guy on the right (don't care to remember the names of people on that channel) said something like "Wow guys, my foot is officially in my mouth" when they were being shown, and talking about, Killzone 2.

No big deal at all. I don't really care for that channel much, but I'm still glad that Little Big Planet won that because unless I missed any other games in that video, they were all shooters except for LBP.

 

Looks like they were focusing on '08 titles.



IllegalPaladin on 18 July 2008

This defense of Little Big Planet is getting rather funny, especially using a 1280x720p resolution for why Little Big Planet apparently dwarfs other games in creative content.

Seriously, step back and take a deep breath.

Spore is doing something never done before, you should just accept that and be excited for the possibilities both games are going to be offering their players.



IllegalPaladin on 18 July 2008
makingmusic476 said:
IllegalPaladin said:

No mention of Killzone 2? I'm mentioning that because that guy on the right (don't care to remember the names of people on that channel) said something like "Wow guys, my foot is officially in my mouth" when they were being shown, and talking about, Killzone 2.

No big deal at all. I don't really care for that channel much, but I'm still glad that Little Big Planet won that because unless I missed any other games in that video, they were all shooters except for LBP.

 

Looks like they were focusing on '08 titles.

 

Ah okay that makes sense.