It seemed very clear since Gears sold more then both GoW and GoW2 so unless Gears is very little advertised which I really doubt since it's a money cow or if it were to fail but its hard to mess up a good formula when you have it, it's going to win. The ony way I see God of War winning is if it does somthing over the top which could happen since there have been almost no details on it. And also since God will be out later as been said before in here.

gears will sell better because it is a shooter on a console with a fanbase that loves shooters, but both will sell well and both will be great.

 I would say neither, because to me they both try too hard.

I think that Gears will sell more, but GOW is the better game.

well they cant really be compared,to which one will be more fun we will see

Wait, not to be a troll or anything, but isn't it RESISTANCE2 that's going head-to-head with GEARS2 this holiday season?

i dont think his game is going to come ouy like nearly a year early.

I would feel more safer making a bet saying it comes out a year late then a year early. well it would follw current trends.

That's not being a troll, that's making sense.

GOW3 FTW! Which is more badass? God of War by far the dude kills heros and gods! Not to mention him being cursed as the ghost of sparta and forever having to wear the ashes of his family!

I think gears may sell better as its a good shooter on a shooter console. Comming out at a time where shooters are huge.