soo, they put gta 4, and not vice city? AND NO POKEMON!!! NO SUPER MARIO 64??? this list saddens me.

There are only two Marios on the list, besides Kart, and Gears deserves its' spot.

Like any lists anyone will put out there there are problems with it but on the overall it is a good list.

Why do I say so? Because most of my all time favorites are on there, not necessarily at the position I'd put them but they are there.

The problems with these lists is that there aren't any real criteria.

There's really only two ways to measure it: either by favorites, or by importance. You can't make an objective list for "best," so don't even try; just call it favorites. But if you want to make a "greatest" list, do it as objectively as possible, using popularity, influence, cultural importance, etc.

And in those terms, this list is AWFUL. No original SMB, no Pokemon, no GT, no the Sims, no Wii Sports, no Sonic, GTAIV instead of GTAIII? But tons of stuff that just amounts to hardcore favorites instead. Pretty useless if this is anything but a group of editors favorite games.

Doom in 3rd I would agree with. But no Pokemon = FAIL

While a number of the games on that list are good... It is full of Fail.
How exactly did they come up with this list?

interesting list, but I enjoyed D/P more than Madden NFL 2005.....

Oblivion doesn't even deserve to be in the top100. Morrowind should've taken Oblivion's position on this list.

COD4 is WAAAAAAY too low on that list. Much better than the vast majority of those games above it. GTA4 at #9? WTF? That game was the single biggest disappointment I've had in the last several years. Don't get me started.

Where is Ninjabread man?