not is against Famitsu, is against their reviews, they review Nintendogs 40/40.

but they have really been off on reviews somtimes,they have rated weak games very high

And how would you have made Nintendogs better?

It's not something I would buy, but if it does what it's supposed to perfectly, why not give it a high score?

 True, but that is a single game. All their other perfect 40 scoerers were exceptional games (even if undeserving of perfection). I mean they're still better than most western magazines or websites that hand out half a dozen or so perfect 10's each year. 

You think before you speak. Famitsu is known for rating their games due to advertisement/sponsoring, hype and fan service.

You should never use Famitsu reviews as reputable sources. 

 Which is why Famitsu has only 7 (SEVEN) perfect scoring games in their entire history.

They did give Lair a 33 with two of the editors giving it a 9. Yea, I think I'll lump Famitsu with the rest of the publications that I think are overrating games.

I give this thread a 9.2.

ok maybe they havent given that many perfect scores,but they do giva alot of bad games high scores

Well they are Japanese. What they find entertaining is not always what western players like.

I think they do as good a job as anyone else (although that's not saying much)