No one said GH3 was hardcore, but you ignore the implications of your argument. Guitar Hero III is not successful because someone wrote "CASUAL!" in invisible ink on the cover of every copyof the game. It sold because it's an enjoyable music game. By simplifying every single game into "casual" and "hardcore" you disrespect them for what they actually are and ceate new problems. If Guitar Hero sells solely because it's casual, does that make the 360 the king of casual due to GH3 sales?

And all of SE's PSP rehashes are low budget. You can't prattle off a few franchise names and then pretend that the low budget ports don't exist.

 I said before I think it is more to due with the fact that Nintendo does not market their 3rd party games as much as they should. Which is why I felt that games like Zack and Wiki, Trauma Center and No More Heroes hasn't sold as well as they should have. Has nothing to do with how large the budget is. Low budget has never meant a game is poor just as how a large budget does not mean a game is good.

MS doesn't make their 3rd party games (of course, duh) but they still try to advertise, which is why they sell so well, even if that 3rd party exclusive is bad.

Do I think they could never sell, of course not, but with their history of 3rd party non casual sales I feel an exclusive release would be a bad move on SE's part, considering they know many PS3 fans as well are looking forward to this game.

It just seems people believe I am completely against a Wii release period which I have stated from the start of this discussion I am not.

The Wii's software sell through rate based on Nintendo's end of the fiscal year earning report for fiscal year 2007 (April 2007-end of March 200: Almopst 120 million! That's correct. It's not a typo. Nintendo in one year sold almost 120 million units of software compared to the PS3 life time sell through rate so far of almost 58 million. an advantage of nearly 3 to 1. Out of that number, around 40% goes to Nintendo first-party, the rest third party. Meaning third-party have 70 million units to slice between themselves! STILL higher than the PS3's lifetime total (For comparison's sakes, Nintendo sold almost 150 million software units to date compared to almost 58 million for PS3)! That isn't just an @$$ kicking, it's an @$$ stomping! A lot of developers who juts thought, "Great, lets just shovel some same ol same ol game onto the Wii and make a quick buck are probably kicking themselves right now!" while companies like Capcom, who develop games like Zack and Wiki, RE4, and devleopers like Suda 51 with No More Heroes are very happy with their sales! That's what developers are looking at! Comparing say, attach ratio of 7 (MS), 6(Nintendo) and around 5 or so (SOny) is meaningless when you look at total software sales of 120 million (Nintendo) and life time sales of 58 million (SOny).

Once again you ingore my post which explains why your reasoning is wrong.  Most games advertised by sony or microsoft are either games where exclusivity was purchased with it as part of it, or where they want their system to be seen as the ideal system to get said game.

What was the last Square game to be advertised by Sony? 

 I did not respond because your continuing to drag this off topic and I intend to stay on topic. I was never speaking with you originally and have no reason to answer either. You came in out of nowhere and attacked my opinion given to another user. Sometimes people are not 100% correct and that is fine. Your not right all the time either.

I felt I gave good reasons why an exclusive would not be a good choice and whether you like it or not it is my opinion and I will stick to it.

Nintendo doesn't have to market other people's games at all, so saying they aren't marketing as much as they should doesn't make any sense when they're not obligated in the slightest. If the 3rd parties are incompetent at marketing their own products it's not something Nintendo should pay (literally) for.

MS only advertise the games that directly benefit them and hurts Sony. Considering they have a lot more money to burn, it's not really a surprise.

You continuously cite Zack & Wiki, No More Heroes, and Trauma Center, ignoring the fact that they are successful. Saying they didn't sell as much as you feel is, quite frankly, an asinine argument for multiple reasons. One, something so vague could be chalked up to 50 million sales for each game. Second, it's not about you but the games themselves, all of which were a success. Third, you can spin it however you like...something we're clearly seeing by you either ignoring these games success or simply being incapable of recgnizing reality.

But it's nice to see the truth come out. KH3 on the Wii is a bad idea not because 3rd party games magically don't sell. It's because the PS3 fans wouldn't like it.

 There is where you look foolish.

How many times in the beginning of this thread and now do I need to repeat that I have zero problems with a Wii release? I just do not agree on a Wii exclusive.

From 1st page.

 Have I not stuck with this from the the beginning? Have I ever stated I thought it shouldn't be on the Wii at all?

With the argument of not knowing how a big budget non casual game on the Wii would sell also adds to why it shouldn't be exclusive.

Then what's the point of having it on the Wii?

Why half way do the best thing that the Wii has got going for it.

OT: I don't see the point of the question. It probably won't start in pre-production til at earliest 2009.

KH 3 iz 2010 GOTY confirmed!!!!1!1!!!!

How is proving your opinion wrong on the basis that the same logic can be used to say it shouldn't be on PS3 off topic?

You simply don't want to admit your reasoning is flawed and therefore you are wrong and have to come up with some other reason to believe it will be on PS3 rather then think your being unbiased on the subject.

You are continueing the same "off topic" discussion with other posters.

RPG sales are more on topic then "non casual core" titles. 

 Agreed, I think I am done arguing in this thread. Smarter to just wait and hope for a multi-platform release.