By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - GTA just became the highest rated game ever, beating OoT!

firebush03 said:



That said, seeing unanimous 10s does come off a tad bit disingenuous IMO. For there to be so many on this site (myself included) who GTA does not appeal to, the uniformity of “This is perfect!” among reviews just rubs me in a certain way. Very happy for Rockstar, in any case! Truly a game that seems worthy of its flowers.

Halen said:

https://multiplayer.it/recensioni/gta-6-recensione.html

The game is not perfect, yet they gave it a 100/100 score. What a shame

Chrkeller said:

Scores, for me, don't matter. I have tried RDR2, GTA3, GTAVC and GTAIV. I just don't like Rockstar. I find their games boring and clunky. I never understood the love affair, but to each their own.

Yeah I do kinda suspect the crazy amount of perfect 100's is partially just due to hype, basically they are expected to give it perfect scores cuz it is the biggest launch ever. GTA fans reviewing the game they've been waiting years for and it's what they wanted and the most hyped game launch ever so they feel they gotta give it perfect scores. While a game doesn't have to be perfect to get a 100, cuz no game is perfect, giving a game a perfect score while saying there's a bunch of stuff not great about it smells very strongly of just reviewing based on hype.

The graphics are completely insane though I'll give it that. Just watching the videos of it I was thinking to myself that if any game ever looks better than this it'll be a complete waste of monetary resources for no purpose haha. And it does sound very immersive, presumably the biggest most in depth game of all time. You can tell this is the biggest budget game ever by a wide margin. So I'm sure for people who don't find the GTA gameplay loop gets old quick, it's probably deserving of a score close to 100.

But if it's just the same gameplay but bigger and prettier and more immersive, to me I feel like is that really deserving of a perfect score?

Not trying to pick on GTA just cuz I find them boring haha at least the older ones that I've played. To be fair I think the same overhyping reviews happened this month for OoT as well, cuz as great as that game is (and it did deserve 99 at the time it came out cuz it was completely revolutionary), 95 today for a game that is early 3D era gameplay and scope with modern graphics, and lacking in some very identifiable areas compared to top games today is a bit legacy/fanboy/hype reviewing over honest reviewing.



Around the Network
angrypoolman said:

GTA is like an iPhone. Super hyped, super advanced, but ultimately has no lasting impact and gets disregarded as soon as the new thing comes out.

Tell that to my iPhone Duo. This thing is awesome! Fits super nice in a single hand and in a pocket, and you have the option to use it like an iPad Mini. In the iPad Mini mode, it really reminds me of how it feels to hold a 3DS. Feels very comfy in the hands. My iPhone 12 was a dinosaur lasting 6 years, and my MacBook Air from 2018 is still going.



firebush03 said:
angrypoolman said:

GTA is like an iPhone. Super hyped, super advanced, but ultimately has no lasting impact and gets disregarded as soon as the new thing comes out.

Tell that to my iPhone Duo. This thing is awesome! Fits super nice in a single hand and in a pocket, and you have the option to use it like an iPad Mini. In the iPad Mini mode, it really reminds me of how it feels to hold a 3DS. Feels very comfy in the hands. My iPhone 12 was a dinosaur lasting 6 years, and my MacBook Air from 2018 is still going.

The point is that this is the type of game that gets discarded as soon as a new one comes out. If you got a nee macbook or iphone you would have no need for the older one. On the other hand, games like ocarina of time and majoras mask are timeless and are always being revisited even though more advanced games have been released since then. You cant replace these games. GTA 4 is replaceable and there has been no reason to use it since 5 came out. And now that 6 is out there will be no reason to use 5 anymore. And the same thing will happen to 6. 



Total Championships: Nintendo - 4, Sony - 2, Atari - 1, Microsoft - 0, Sega - 0

angrypoolman said:
firebush03 said:

Tell that to my iPhone Duo. This thing is awesome! Fits super nice in a single hand and in a pocket, and you have the option to use it like an iPad Mini. In the iPad Mini mode, it really reminds me of how it feels to hold a 3DS. Feels very comfy in the hands. My iPhone 12 was a dinosaur lasting 6 years, and my MacBook Air from 2018 is still going.

The point is that this is the type of game that gets discarded as soon as a new one comes out. If you got a nee macbook or iphone you would have no need for the older one. On the other hand, games like ocarina of time and majoras mask are timeless and are always being revisited even though more advanced games have been released since then. You cant replace these games. GTA 4 is replaceable and there has been no reason to use it since 5 came out. And now that 6 is out there will be no reason to use 5 anymore. And the same thing will happen to 6. 

GTA IV will be remastered and will sell just like the GTA 3 / Vice City / San Andreas. The games are a mirror of their time and have their own stories and settings.

To each their own. I enjoyed OoT when it came out but I have no desire to play it again and find, WindWaker, Okami, BotW and TotK all standing well above OoT and I have actually replayed WindWaker and Okami. (Although not finished Okami a second time, too long lol)

GTA 5 will come back as well, first the current version has to stop selling though lol.

OoT is replaceable for many as well. 



Strange...
GTA is the best reviewed game in almost 30 years and we can't see such bombastic news in VG Chartzs front page.



Around the Network
SvennoJ said:
angrypoolman said:

The point is that this is the type of game that gets discarded as soon as a new one comes out. If you got a nee macbook or iphone you would have no need for the older one. On the other hand, games like ocarina of time and majoras mask are timeless and are always being revisited even though more advanced games have been released since then. You cant replace these games. GTA 4 is replaceable and there has been no reason to use it since 5 came out. And now that 6 is out there will be no reason to use 5 anymore. And the same thing will happen to 6. 

GTA IV will be remastered and will sell just like the GTA 3 / Vice City / San Andreas. The games are a mirror of their time and have their own stories and settings.

To each their own. I enjoyed OoT when it came out but I have no desire to play it again and find, WindWaker, Okami, BotW and TotK all standing well above OoT and I have actually replayed WindWaker and Okami. (Although not finished Okami a second time, too long lol)

GTA 5 will come back as well, first the current version has to stop selling though lol.

OoT is replaceable for many as well. 

I mean.. honestly the actual game on the other side is irrelevant. By and large GTA games are discarded like an old pair of shoes whereas OoT and many of the other games you have listed are not. Its like a madden game except it doesnt come out every year. 



Total Championships: Nintendo - 4, Sony - 2, Atari - 1, Microsoft - 0, Sega - 0

angrypoolman said:
SvennoJ said:

GTA IV will be remastered and will sell just like the GTA 3 / Vice City / San Andreas. The games are a mirror of their time and have their own stories and settings.

To each their own. I enjoyed OoT when it came out but I have no desire to play it again and find, WindWaker, Okami, BotW and TotK all standing well above OoT and I have actually replayed WindWaker and Okami. (Although not finished Okami a second time, too long lol)

GTA 5 will come back as well, first the current version has to stop selling though lol.

OoT is replaceable for many as well. 

I mean.. honestly the actual game on the other side is irrelevant. By and large GTA games are discarded like an old pair of shoes whereas OoT and many of the other games you have listed are not. Its like a madden game except it doesnt come out every year. 

That's your opinion. Why did GTA definitive edition sell 10 million copies in November 2021 in 2 months if its irrelevant and discarded?

Each game has their own map, different vibe, different story. 

You could argue TotK makes BotW obsolete since the map is re-used and expanded on, gameplay refined and expanded on, but I'm sure many people will still want to replay BotW. Its Switch 2 sales are most likely not all new players.



Zelda ocarina of time remake got a vgchartz article claiming it to be the highest rated game of the year.
Grand theft auto VI becomes the highest rated game of all time and not a single peep.
🫠
Blindfolds on i guess. Pathetic.



SvennoJ said:
angrypoolman said:

I mean.. honestly the actual game on the other side is irrelevant. By and large GTA games are discarded like an old pair of shoes whereas OoT and many of the other games you have listed are not. Its like a madden game except it doesnt come out every year. 

That's your opinion. Why did GTA definitive edition sell 10 million copies in November 2021 in 2 months if its irrelevant and discarded?

Each game has their own map, different vibe, different story. 

You could argue TotK makes BotW obsolete since the map is re-used and expanded on, gameplay refined and expanded on, but I'm sure many people will still want to replay BotW. Its Switch 2 sales are most likely not all new players.

Why did a 3 pack of remastered gta ps2 games sell 10 million? Because it came out. The fanbase is massive, so naturally any release is going to get millions of sales. They can release gta: federation force and itll probably sell 10 million regardless just because it is gta. Nobody is actually playing the original games anymore. Gta 4 is like what the 4th best rated game of all time or something? Nobody cares about that game. It was hype when it came out and now people have moved on. Its not remembered as anything special. Am I wrong? I never see gta 4 cited as an all time great even though it reviewed as highly as it did. I never, ever see that. Red dead redemption 2, on the other hand, i see people still regard that very high. 



Total Championships: Nintendo - 4, Sony - 2, Atari - 1, Microsoft - 0, Sega - 0

angrypoolman said:
SvennoJ said:

That's your opinion. Why did GTA definitive edition sell 10 million copies in November 2021 in 2 months if its irrelevant and discarded?

Each game has their own map, different vibe, different story. 

You could argue TotK makes BotW obsolete since the map is re-used and expanded on, gameplay refined and expanded on, but I'm sure many people will still want to replay BotW. Its Switch 2 sales are most likely not all new players.

Why did a 3 pack of remastered gta ps2 games sell 10 million? Because it came out. The fanbase is massive, so naturally any release is going to get millions of sales. They can release gta: federation force and itll probably sell 10 million regardless just because it is gta. Nobody is actually playing the original games anymore. Gta 4 is like what the 4th best rated game of all time or something? Nobody cares about that game. It was hype when it came out and now people have moved on. Its not remembered as anything special. Am I wrong? I never see gta 4 cited as an all time great even though it reviewed as highly as it did. I never, ever see that. Red dead redemption 2, on the other hand, i see people still regard that very high. 

You do realize those games are 10 years apart, GTA 4 came out in 2008, RDR2 in 2018, and there are also still people that prefer the original RDR over RDR2, it got a remaster last year. 

There is plenty fan demand for GTA 4 and the game is still played on Steam
https://www.ggrecon.com/articles/gta-4-steam-players-beat-ps2-gtas/

You not caring about a game != nobody cares.