By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - GTA just became the highest rated game ever, beating OoT!

Slownenberg said:
Chrkeller said:

With ease.  Your Nintendo preference is showing big time.

Ocarina remake sold 5.8 million.  Lol, a Vice City remake would pre-order double that and sell 4x, if not more.

I say this as someone who thinks Ocarina is the GOAT and Zelda is the best franchise in gaming, and doesn't personally like GTA.

GTA smokes any single Nintendo game in regards to impact.  It ain't close.  Your take is insane.  GTA5 is still selling 10 million a year.

Think about it, there is a good chance that GTA5 outsells Ocarina remake this year, like seriously.

Both of you have made good points.

I'd just say don't confuse sales with impact. For example, sports games and CoD sells tons every year, but other than the initial Modern Warfare that made CoD huge, I don't think too many people would talk about the "impact" of those games other than showing you can rehash a game annually and keep selling it to the same fans, often making the previous game obsolete for most people.

Zelda sales are a joke compared to GTA, but literally every game save Minecraft is a joke compared to GTA. In gaming, people love to shoot things and blow things up, GTA is the ultimate popular franchise for that. Sword adventure game is never gonna be as popular as that. Explosions and bullets beat swords by a wide margin, apparently.

So sure a Vice City remake would sell more than OoT, but unless they spent half a billion dollars and 10 years to upgrade it to the level of GTA VI, which would just make it a totally new game, people would quickly stop caring about it no matter how much it sold and just go back to the much more advanced new GTA VI.

Whereas with OoT that is not the case at all, even though the open world Zeldas have blown away OoT not just in popularity but in most gameplay aspects, to the point where going back to old style Zelda games would be a massive step backwards for the series, but OoT is still a unique game well worth playing despite all the Zeldas that have come since. GTA games moving to a different city to do same stuff but more stuff doesn't really compare to the uniqueness of each Zelda, and therefore can't have the sort of impact, individually, that the better or more revolutionary Zelda games (LoZ, LttP, OoT, BotW) have had.

But despite good sales, nobody is buying the PS2 GTA ports and saying it's the best game ever. They're probably picking it up and being like oh these are really dated now compared to current game and putting it down after a few hours of play. Just like while I played a ton of MK64 in high school and loved it, playing it on NSO I was like oh okay it's alright haha I'd rather just play MK8D, whereas timeless unique classics like LoZ, SMB3, OoT, etc are still a blast to play and you don't get basically the same but better experience by playing the latest version of them, each one is unique with its own impact beyond just "I played this a ton when I was younger". So OoT on the other hand is apparently a game that lots of people play over and over and have beat dozens of times and are absolutely loving getting to play it now with modern graphics.

GTA 3 had a big impact in terms of establishing the general open world formula and specifically the GTA formula going forward and its popularity. But after that it's kinda just been iteratively advancing the same formula as far as I can tell. GTA VI may very well make a name for itself as having the most stuff to do in a game ever and the most interacting systems of any game ever, but still pretty sure it's the same basic formula as the rest of the GTA games. It's impact is probably gonna mostly be just sheer size, budget, and sales related, and not like "it's such a unique game it'll still be a favorite after GTA VII comes out". It'll probably be completely replaced by GTA 7 for most people.

Can't really say any individual GTA game, other than 3 which broke new ground, has the impact of a groundbreaking Zelda, because that franchise makes completely new games pretty much every time (BotW->TotK not withstanding) so each game tends to be a unique moment in gaming, where the best entries (like OoT and BotW) have a big impact in gaming.

For comparison, think about Mario Kart. Way better sales than Zelda. Even MKW which seems to be considered quite flawed and a gameplay downgrade from MK8, is gonna probably blow away the sales of BotW or whatever new Zelda comes out this gen. Would you say any specific MK, including the huge selling MK8, has more "impact" than LoZ/LttP/OoT/BotW? I sure wouldn't. Even though each MK is different they are samey enough to blend together in terms of impact of the series as a whole rather than an individual title. That's GTA. Whereas Zelda has more impact individually (at least the most famous ones) as the games are totally unique.

Sorry, that was way more words than I meant to write haha.

The problem is everything in bold is speculation based on opinion.  There is no evidence that people are still playing Mario 64 in mass while everyone is using GTA3 as a coaster.  

GTA will have a lasting impact.  Claiming otherwise is denial, foolish and/or ignorant.  



rtx 4090, 32 gb ram, i7-13700k

Switch 2

Around the Network

I don't know if anyone in the thread already brought it up but I took the time and compared the actual average from all reviews of OoT and GTAVI and... Idk how metacritic rates games but GTAVI average is 98,7435897436
OoT average is 98,9545454545

So OoT is still higher rated, even though GTA has about 130 more reviews, which possibly is why it's placed above. Not a fair comparison, really, since oot came out in 1998 when most reviews were made in magazines and the data would be harder to collect.



Impressive that GTA6 is even close with so many more reviews and trolls.

Also, lol @ Zelda being impactful. Sure, some Zelda games might do new things for that particular franchise, but not gaming as a whole. When you’re used to so much rehash from Nintendo, something like Breath of the Wild is a great shot in the arm and did a lot for Zelda, but not for gaming.



LudicrousSpeed said:

Impressive that GTA6 is even close with so many more reviews and trolls.

Also, lol @ Zelda being impactful. Sure, some Zelda games might do new things for that particular franchise, but not gaming as a whole. When you’re used to so much rehash from Nintendo, something like Breath of the Wild is a great shot in the arm and did a lot for Zelda, but not for gaming.

BOTW had a MASSIVE impact for gaming as a whole. It still has, and will for a while.



LudicrousSpeed said:

Impressive that GTA6 is even close with so many more reviews and trolls.

Also, lol @ Zelda being impactful. Sure, some Zelda games might do new things for that particular franchise, but not gaming as a whole. When you’re used to so much rehash from Nintendo, something like Breath of the Wild is a great shot in the arm and did a lot for Zelda, but not for gaming.

That’s equally as insane as what the other dude said about GTA in this thread.



Around the Network

Many games have major impact, GTA included. I don't even personally like GTA and love Zelda, but we shouldn't allow personal feelings cloud judgment. Of course GTA has lasting impact, it is a cultural phenomenon. The Switch, as a hybrid design, has massive impact as well. We should celebrate gaming, not make silly wars.

Edit

Reports have GTA6 breaking Twitch records, with 3,300,000 concurrent views...  

Last edited by Chrkeller - 4 hours ago

rtx 4090, 32 gb ram, i7-13700k

Switch 2

zamieh said:

I don't know if anyone in the thread already brought it up but I took the time and compared the actual average from all reviews of OoT and GTAVI and... Idk how metacritic rates games but GTAVI average is 98,7435897436
OoT average is 98,9545454545

So OoT is still higher rated, even though GTA has about 130 more reviews, which possibly is why it's placed above. Not a fair comparison, really, since oot came out in 1998 when most reviews were made in magazines and the data would be harder to collect.

Metacritic gives more weight to certain publications so it's impossible to know the real average behind the rounded number. Also, it is possible that the number of reviews influences the rankings somehow.



Signature goes here!

https://www.forbes.com/sites/antoniopequenoiv/2026/11/18/gta-flu-hits-offices-thursday-heres-how-many-workers-will-call-out/

In the US, full-time employee request for paid time off increased 18% for GTA6's release... meaning almost 1/5 full-time workers are taking the day off to play GTA6.

That is crazy impressive.



rtx 4090, 32 gb ram, i7-13700k

Switch 2

Well I stayed up with my youngest to play the first hour at midnight. Or rather watch him play. It was phenomenal, polished to perfection. Sorry but it replaced BotW "tutorial island" as the best onboarding experience for me. (And OoT took me much longer to get into back in the day) I'm still amazed at how it manages to make you do gameplay in the past that seamlessly fits into the past narrative without any jarring transitions or skipping a beat.

And yes of course GTA has a huge impact on the industry, Saints Row, Watch Dogs, Sleeping Dogs, Mafia, Just Cause, Cyberpunk all inspired by it as well as many more open world sandbox and racing games. GTA 3 made the open world sandbox game popular and keeps raising the bar to beat.

Zelda has a similar impact on the industry, albeit at a bit smaller scale. Still BotW after turning Zelda open world sold over 35 million copies, Comparing franchises before the release of GTA6 has Zelda franchise estimated at close to 195 million total units (34 games and spinoffs/remasters), GTA franchise as 480 million total units sold (16 games and spinoffs/remasters)

Just enjoy what you like.



zamieh said:

I don't know if anyone in the thread already brought it up but I took the time and compared the actual average from all reviews of OoT and GTAVI and... Idk how metacritic rates games but GTAVI average is 98,7435897436
OoT average is 98,9545454545

So OoT is still higher rated, even though GTA has about 130 more reviews, which possibly is why it's placed above. Not a fair comparison, really, since oot came out in 1998 when most reviews were made in magazines and the data would be harder to collect.

Alphabetical?