By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - The 17th Annual Greatest Games Event - The Discussion Thread - Day 47

drbunnig said:
UnderwaterFunktown said:

47) NieR: Automata but the protagonist is shorter and rounder

And probably more powerful despite his cutesy looks

I'm guessing a Kirby game. Planet Robobot?

Bofferbrauer2 said:
UnderwaterFunktown said:

More hints:

50) The space station that came before the sea

The villain of this game was the inspiration for GlaDOS

49) Celebration number quadro Mario Party 4

48) Just a bird on an island

Briefly hiking

47) NieR: Automata but the protagonist is shorter and rounder

And probably more powerful despite his cutesy looks

46) The lesser known second coming of one gaming's greatest narrators

In this game he plays a talking sword, wielded by the protagonist: Red

50: System Shock 

Two cases of right series wrong game.



Try out my free game on Steam

2025 OpenCritic Prediction Leagues

Around the Network
Darashiva said:

More clues.

#50

  • An entire live action film was made for the specific purpose of introducing this game to North American audiences
  • The film was released in 1989

#49

  • Deep Fog of the Old One is slowly consuming the kingdom
  • Set the template for one of the most popular video game genres today

#48 Breath of the Wild

  • I guess I could just go straight to the end

#47

  • The rats are back
  • These siblings just can't catch a break.

#46 (Incorrect guesses: Cadence of Hyrule, Samba de Amigo)

  • A rhythm game created around the music of a single video game franchise (they later added music from other series by the same publisher)
  • You can play songs from every main installment in the series, as well as several spinoffs

49) Demons Souls?

47) A Plagues Tale Requiem (i don't know the titles, but the second one)

46) Final Fantasy Theatrerhythm The Final Bar (again, not sure who can spell that but something along those lines)



Try out my free game on Steam

2025 OpenCritic Prediction Leagues

Bofferbrauer2 said:
Darashiva said:

More clues.

#50

  • An entire live action film was made for the specific purpose of introducing this game to North American audiences
  • The film was released in 1989

#49

  • Deep Fog of the Old One is slowly consuming the kingdom
  • Set the template for one of the most popular video game genres today

#48 Breath of the Wild

  • I guess I could just go straight to the end

#47

  • The rats are back
  • These siblings just can't catch a break.

#46 (Incorrect guesses: Cadence of Hyrule, Samba de Amigo)

  • A rhythm game created around the music of a single video game franchise (they later added music from other series by the same publisher)
  • You can play songs from every main installment in the series, as well as several spinoffs

49: Silent hill?

No, it is Demon's Souls as guessed below.

UnderwaterFunktown said:

More hints:

50) The space station that came before the sea

The villain of this game was the inspiration for GlaDOS

49) Celebration number quadro Mario Party 4

48) Just a bird on an island

Briefly hiking

47) NieR: Automata but the protagonist is shorter and rounder

And probably more powerful despite his cutesy looks

46) The lesser known second coming of one gaming's greatest narrators

In this game he plays a talking sword, wielded by the protagonist: Red

48: A Short Hike?
UnderwaterFunktown said:
Darashiva said:

More clues.

#50

  • An entire live action film was made for the specific purpose of introducing this game to North American audiences
  • The film was released in 1989

#49

  • Deep Fog of the Old One is slowly consuming the kingdom
  • Set the template for one of the most popular video game genres today

#48 Breath of the Wild

  • I guess I could just go straight to the end

#47

  • The rats are back
  • These siblings just can't catch a break.

#46 (Incorrect guesses: Cadence of Hyrule, Samba de Amigo)

  • A rhythm game created around the music of a single video game franchise (they later added music from other series by the same publisher)
  • You can play songs from every main installment in the series, as well as several spinoffs

49) Demons Souls?

47) A Plagues Tale Requiem (i don't know the titles, but the second one)

46) Final Fantasy Theatrerhythm The Final Bar (again, not sure who can spell that but something along those lines)

Correct on all three.



UnderwaterFunktown said:
drbunnig said:

I'm guessing a Kirby game. Planet Robobot?

Bofferbrauer2 said:

50: System Shock 

Two cases of right series wrong game.

System Shock 2 then



Darashiva said:
Bofferbrauer2 said:

49: Silent hill?

No, it is Demon's Souls as guessed below.

UnderwaterFunktown said:

More hints:

50) The space station that came before the sea

The villain of this game was the inspiration for GlaDOS

49) Celebration number quadro Mario Party 4

48) Just a bird on an island

Briefly hiking

47) NieR: Automata but the protagonist is shorter and rounder

And probably more powerful despite his cutesy looks

46) The lesser known second coming of one gaming's greatest narrators

In this game he plays a talking sword, wielded by the protagonist: Red

48: A Short Hike?
UnderwaterFunktown said:

49) Demons Souls?

47) A Plagues Tale Requiem (i don't know the titles, but the second one)

46) Final Fantasy Theatrerhythm The Final Bar (again, not sure who can spell that but something along those lines)

Correct on all three.

Bofferbrauer2 said:
UnderwaterFunktown said:
Bofferbrauer2 said:

50: System Shock 

Two cases of right series wrong game.

System Shock 2 then

Yep and yep



Try out my free game on Steam

2025 OpenCritic Prediction Leagues

Around the Network

49: Unlike all the other in the series, no transformations here, sorry! Shantae and the Pirate's Curse, as found out by @UnderwaterFunktown 

  1. Hint: Has an Arabic theme
  2. Is also known for it's music; especially the one from theme from the main town is highly regarded.

48: A webcomic artist, a Russian mercenary, a loudmouthed luchador and a lagomorph walk into a bar... Poker Night at the Inventory, as (mostly) found out by @UnderwaterFunktown 

  1. Hint: ...to play a game hosted by a retired pirate.
  2. A game of Poker, to be exact.

47: This game for the venerable C64 and Amiga won many awards for it's music

  1. Hint: It takes many cues from Metroid
  2. It has a NES port that is notable for having the prefix Super added to its name despite the SNES/ Super Nintendo already having released a whole ago - which got a port with the exact same name a year later.

45: In this RPG, you need to rule the console business, including the development of new games

  1. Hint: In the game world, Nintendo existed, but by the game's start they already went bankrupt or at least pushed out of the console market.

44: Racing with a friend in the same vehicle

And while we're at it, here are the honorable mentions that got kicked out:

H2: A PC exclusive pinball game with a horror theme with 3 tables: Castle (complete with a cemetery), Dungeon and Laboratory (with Frankenstein's Monster on the lab table)

  1. Hint: It's part of a pinball series by Sierra On-Line
  2. It's the second of the series, with he first one having a Sci->fi theme (visually based on their game Outpost), and the successor having many smaller tables around a dinosaur theme instead of 3 big ones.
Last edited by Bofferbrauer2 - 2 days ago

Bofferbrauer2 said:

49: Unlike all the other in the series, no transformations here, sorry!

  1. Hint: Has an Arabic theme
  2. Is also known for it's music; especially the one from theme from the main town is highly regarded.

48: A webcomic artist, a Russian mercenary, a loudmouthed luchador and a lagomorph walk into a bar...

  1. Hint: ...to play a game hosted by a retired pirate.
  2. A game of Poker, to be exact.

47: This game for the venerable C64 and Amiga won many awards for it's music

  1. Hint: It takes many cues from Metroid
  2. It has a NES port that is notable for having the prefix Super added to its name despite the SNES/ Super Nintendo already having released a whole ago - which got a port with the exact same name a year later.

45: In this RPG, you need to rule the console business, including the development of new games

  1. Hint: In the game world, Nintendo existed, but by the game's start they already went bankrupt or at least pushed out of the console market.

44: Racing with a friend in the same vehicle

And while we're at it, here are the honorable mentions that got kicked out:

H2: A PC exclusive pinball game with a horror theme with 3 tables: Castle (complete with a cemetery), Dungeon and Laboratory (with Frankenstein's Monster on the lab table)

  1. Hint: It's part of a pinball series by Sierra On-Line
  2. It's the second of the series, with he first one having a Sci->fi theme (visually based on their game Outpost), and the successor having many smaller tables around a dinosaur theme instead of 3 big ones.

49) Shantae and the Pirates Curse (I don't know which shantae I must admit)

48) Poker Night on steam (not sure if that's the exact name)



Try out my free game on Steam

2025 OpenCritic Prediction Leagues

UnderwaterFunktown said:
Bofferbrauer2 said:

49: Unlike all the other in the series, no transformations here, sorry!

  1. Hint: Has an Arabic theme
  2. Is also known for it's music; especially the one from theme from the main town is highly regarded.

48: A webcomic artist, a Russian mercenary, a loudmouthed luchador and a lagomorph walk into a bar...

  1. Hint: ...to play a game hosted by a retired pirate.
  2. A game of Poker, to be exact.

47: This game for the venerable C64 and Amiga won many awards for it's music

  1. Hint: It takes many cues from Metroid
  2. It has a NES port that is notable for having the prefix Super added to its name despite the SNES/ Super Nintendo already having released a whole ago - which got a port with the exact same name a year later.

45: In this RPG, you need to rule the console business, including the development of new games

  1. Hint: In the game world, Nintendo existed, but by the game's start they already went bankrupt or at least pushed out of the console market.

44: Racing with a friend in the same vehicle

And while we're at it, here are the honorable mentions that got kicked out:

H2: A PC exclusive pinball game with a horror theme with 3 tables: Castle (complete with a cemetery), Dungeon and Laboratory (with Frankenstein's Monster on the lab table)

  1. Hint: It's part of a pinball series by Sierra On-Line
  2. It's the second of the series, with he first one having a Sci->fi theme (visually based on their game Outpost), and the successor having many smaller tables around a dinosaur theme instead of 3 big ones.

49) Shantae and the Pirates Curse (I don't know which shantae I must admit)

48) Poker Night on steam (not sure if that's the exact name)

I'll count both.

Shantae and the Pirate's Curse was indeed the correct Shantae game, while the other's full name is Poker Night at the Inventory.



50

Change YoY: -2             My Rating: 9.1 / 10

I have a feeling this is going to be the last time I'll be writing about Super Mario Bros. 3 in this particular context. It has been on my list ever since I first started participating in these Greatest Games Events back in 2016, I think. However, over the years it has slowly, but steadily been dropping further and further down on my list, and now it has found itself at the very end of my top 50. Next year, I expect to no longer see it here. That is not to say the game is any less excellent. But, what exactly is there left to say about Super Mario Bros. 3 that just about everyone else hasn't already repeated countless times over the last several decades? One of the most legendary and beloved video games of all time, often still considered by many to be among the very best 2D platformers ever created, and a game whose influence can still be seen and felt in the genre to this day.

I do still remember when I got Super Mario Bros. 3 somewhere around 1993 or 94, a few years after its original release in the PAL regions. My cousin was no longer into video games that much, and he was getting rid of his NES games, so obviously I took all of them off his hands. Though there were quite a few very good games among them, like Kirby's Adventure, for example, it was SMB3 that remains my favourite of the entire NES library. Even by today's standards it remains a near flawless game in a lot of ways. The platforming is precise, the colourful graphics are some of the best on the console, and most importantly, it's simply just fun to play. If I was ranking this game based on pure gameplay, Super Mario Bros. 3 would probably be quite a bit higher on the list. As it stands, it's one of the few games on my list that are there almost entirely on the merits of its gameplay, and one that's still worth playing today.

   



New round of hints:

47: This game for the venerable C64 and Amiga won many awards for it's music

  1. Hint: It takes many cues from Metroid
  2. It has a NES port that is notable for having the prefix Super added to its name despite the SNES/ Super Nintendo already having released a whole ago - which got a port with the exact same name a year later.
  3. There is also a Megadrive port with the Mega prefix

45: In this RPG, you need to rule the console business, including the development of new games

  1. Hint: In the game world, Nintendo existed, but by the game's start they already went bankrupt or at least pushed out of the console market.
  2. For the endgame, the RPG suddenly turns into a Shoot'em up Boss rush with consoles as the boss opponents shooting sprites at your ship

44: Racing with a friend in the same vehicle Mario Kart: Double Dash, as found out by @TruckOSaurus 

  1. Hint: Each Duo has it's own special weapon

43: A God Game where you literally play a God guiding a civilization from the stone age to the space age

42: No insult swordfighting in this one, sadly.

And while we're at it, here are the honorable mentions that got kicked out:

H2: A PC exclusive pinball game with a horror theme with 3 tables: Castle (complete with a cemetery), Dungeon and Laboratory (with Frankenstein's Monster on the lab table)

  1. Hint: It's part of a pinball series by Sierra On-Line
  2. It's the second of the series, with he first one having a Sci->fi theme (visually based on their game Outpost), and the successor having many smaller tables around a dinosaur theme instead of 3 big ones.
  3. Part of the 3D Ultra series of games from the publisher
Last edited by Bofferbrauer2 - 1 day ago