If include the entirety of each series, which do you think is better overall, Halo, or Gears of War?
Which is greater overall? | |||
| Halo | 15 | 75.00% | |
| Gears | 5 | 25.00% | |
| Total: | 20 | ||


If include the entirety of each series, which do you think is better overall, Halo, or Gears of War?


Gears. Easily. Even 4 and 5 are solid games. Not the best in the series but even they are better than whatever 343 did. E-Day has the best campaign in the series so Coalition is doing fine without Epic. Halo fell on it's ass without Bungie. Halo and Gears 1 defined a console generation. 2 and 3 for both were amazing. Gears 4-5 still better than what happened to Halo.

Halo 1-3 > Gears 1-3, imo. Everything else I can't really comment on because I didn't spend much time beyond their trilogies. To me, they began and ended there.






That’s a tough one. I haven’t yet played E-Day, so keep that in mind.
Halo started off in a much stronger way. Halo:CE is better than Gears 1. Halo 2 is better than Gears 2. Halo 3 and Gears 3 are probably tied. I’ll take ODST and Reach over Judgment.
However, things changed dramatically after Bungie left the franchise. I’ll take Gears 4 over Halo 4 every day of the week. Same for Gears 5 over Halo 5.
But I don’t think that’s quite enough. Halo from 2001-2010 is just so damn good — untouchable, really. I believe that golden age is enough to compensate for the rough years afterward.
Halo during it's peak versus Gears, I pick Halo. Unfortunately Halo has been more inconsistent and more controversial than Gears from Halo 4 and Gears 4 onward. Gears Eday is the closest we've gotten to a return to form for Gears and does a lot of things very well. Halo Infinite came close to achieving a comback for Halo. It felt amazing to play but it was plagued with too many issues.


Halo Infinite has the ugliest open world I have ever seen in a AAA game. Xenoblade X is better looking than that games world.

I voted Gears because i think those games are better. I couldnt get into Halo not even at the peak, it just never grew on me.
That said, Halo is probably more influential all things considered.








Original Halo trilogy I enjoy more than the original Gears of War trilogy. However, since then Gears has had a better run of games. Gears 4 and 5 are better than Halo 4, 5, and Infinite. Gears of War E-Day IMO is as good (if not better - I'm still playing through it) as peak Gears of War, while Halo Campaign Evolved is well yeahhhhh not the best.
So that makes it a tough choice. overall quality Gears of War is better. But that nostalgia for the original Halo.
Last edited by trunkswd - on 19 October 2026VGChartz Sales Analyst and Writer - William D'Angelo - I stream on Twitch and have my own YouTube channel discussing gaming sales and news, as well as posting random gaming content. Follow me on Bluesky.
I post and adjust the VGChartz hardware estimates, with help from Machina.
Writer of the Sales Comparison | Monthly Hardware Breakdown | Monthly Sales Analysis | Marketshare Features, as well as daily news on the Video Game Industry.


| Leynos said: Gears. Easily. Even 4 and 5 are solid games. Not the best in the series but even they are better than whatever 343 did. E-Day has the best campaign in the series so Coalition is doing fine without Epic. Halo fell on it's ass without Bungie. Halo and Gears 1 defined a console generation. 2 and 3 for both were amazing. Gears 4-5 still better than what happened to Halo. |
Yeah granted I haven't gotten around to E-day or Halo Infinite/5 yet but I also did feel Gears held up better over time than Halo, even if Halo had the higher high point back in the day.
I actually just got done with Gears 4, and it was solid. Also really liked Judgement. I don't think I'd rank any Gears quite as highly as Combat Evolved or Reach, but I would put Gears 1-3 above say Halo 3, ODST, 4.
Halo peaked much higher than Gears, on almost all levels. From 2001 until 2009 it was the most popular FPS on the planet, being an Xbox exclusive on the PS2 era,