By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Leynos said:

Gears. Easily. Even 4 and 5 are solid games. Not the best in the series but even they are better than whatever 343 did. E-Day has the best campaign in the series so Coalition is doing fine without Epic. Halo fell on it's ass without Bungie. Halo and Gears 1 defined a console generation. 2 and 3 for both were amazing. Gears 4-5 still better than what happened to Halo.

Yeah granted I haven't gotten around to E-day or Halo Infinite/5 yet but I also did feel Gears held up better over time than Halo, even if Halo had the higher high point back in the day.

I actually just got done with Gears 4, and it was solid. Also really liked Judgement. I don't think I'd rank any Gears quite as highly as Combat Evolved or Reach, but I would put Gears 1-3 above say Halo 3, ODST, 4.