By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Which series is ultimately greater, Mario or Zelda? (and why)

 

Which one is greater?

Mario 20 48.78%
 
Zelda 21 51.22%
 
Total:41
tucotuti said:
curl-6 said:

Any particular one?

Difficult to say! Probably the OG super mario for the NES, or maybe directly Mario Odyssey

Nice.

For me I think it'd be Galaxy 1, both cos it's basically a perfect game in my view, and cos I think any aliens that make it out here to visit us would find our take on 'space' cute and endearing in a primitive kind of way.



Around the Network
tucotuti said:

If aliens came to Earth and asked what is a video game, I would give them a Mario game.

I’d give them Metroid or Earthbound.

I think they’d really dig a Hip Tanaka soundtrack.



I describe myself as a little dose of toxic masculinity.

The poll has seesawed mutliple times now, from Mario winning, to Zelda winning, back to Mario, etc.

Seems a really close one in most people's minds.



IMO, both series peaked on the NES.  Both seriously declined since then.  I really hate Wind Waker, Mario 64 and Mario Odyssey.  I'm also afraid to play Skyward Sword in that I might hate it even more than Wind Waker.  However, the Zelda series recovered majorly with Breath of the Wild.  The Mario series never had such an amazing recovery.

Zelda wins.



The_Liquid_Laser said:

IMO, both series peaked on the NES.  Both seriously declined since then.  I really hate Wind Waker, Mario 64 and Mario Odyssey.  I'm also afraid to play Skyward Sword in that I might hate it even more than Wind Waker.  However, the Zelda series recovered majorly with Breath of the Wild.  The Mario series never had such an amazing recovery.

Zelda wins.



Around the Network
curl-6 said:

The poll has seesawed mutliple times now, from Mario winning, to Zelda winning, back to Mario, etc.

Seems a really close one in most people's minds.

That is the thing, it shouldnt even be a question. Mario is far bigger and much more important franchise then Zelda ever was or will ever be. I rly dont know what is in mind of people who voted Zelda. 



ST.Tachyon said:
curl-6 said:

The poll has seesawed mutliple times now, from Mario winning, to Zelda winning, back to Mario, etc.

Seems a really close one in most people's minds.

That is the thing, it shouldnt even be a question. Mario is far bigger and much more important franchise then Zelda ever was or will ever be. I rly dont know what is in mind of people who voted Zelda. 

The only criteria The Legend of Zelda could top Mario is Quality, but, even this one, is not garanteed as Mario is as consistent good as Zelda. All the other criteria ((importance, popularity), Mario wins over Zelda



ST.Tachyon said:
curl-6 said:

The poll has seesawed mutliple times now, from Mario winning, to Zelda winning, back to Mario, etc.

Seems a really close one in most people's minds.

That is the thing, it shouldnt even be a question. Mario is far bigger and much more important franchise then Zelda ever was or will ever be. I rly dont know what is in mind of people who voted Zelda. 

I think it's pretty obvious if you read the posts. Many (not all) people are voting on which series is better in terms of quality. That's what I did.

Curl articulated the guidelines of the thread here: https://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=9674057



CourageTCD said:
ST.Tachyon said:

That is the thing, it shouldnt even be a question. Mario is far bigger and much more important franchise then Zelda ever was or will ever be. I rly dont know what is in mind of people who voted Zelda. 

The only criteria The Legend of Zelda could top Mario is Quality, but, even this one, is not garanteed as Mario is as consistent good as Zelda. All the other criteria ((importance, popularity), Mario wins over Zelda

Even quality is not on Zelda games.

Yeah, sure you have much more things to do in Zelda games because they are more about exploration then anything else so some people will think of that as quality but when it comes to innovation, gameplay and art style Mario wins that easily. So even when it comes to quality Mario games are ahead of Zelda.



ST.Tachyon said:
CourageTCD said:

The only criteria The Legend of Zelda could top Mario is Quality, but, even this one, is not garanteed as Mario is as consistent good as Zelda. All the other criteria ((importance, popularity), Mario wins over Zelda

Even quality is not on Zelda games.

Yeah, sure you have much more things to do in Zelda games because they are more about exploration then anything else so some people will think of that as quality but when it comes to innovation, gameplay and art style Mario wins that easily. So even when it comes to quality Mario games are ahead of Zelda.

Eh. That's more of a subjective perspective though. No one game is objectively better (in terms of quality) than the other. I love myself some Mario just as much as I love myself some Zelda— it's hard for me to really compare quality given how distinct each franchise is.