The Last of Us, Uncharted 2, GTA5, Destiny, and Heavy Rain.

TESV: Skyrim
Uncharted 2
Fallout 3
The Last of Us
Sports Champions
Uncharted 3
God of War III
Dead Space
Fallout: New Vegas
Mortal Kombat (2011)
Far Cry 3
BioShock
Dark Souls
Dragon's Dogma
Mass Effect 2
Portal 2

The Ico & Shadow of the Colossus Collection, Portal/The Orange Box, Portal 2, and BioShock.

Of the ones that made the final cut, I had the most fun with the Ratchet & Clank Future series. Uncharted 2 was the best Uncharted game, followed by the first one. But the 3rd one wasn't as good as the other two.

I thought that there was a sort of consensus that the first game was the least enjoyable of the three Uncarted games on PS3 by a large margin. I cannot think of a single thing that I consider better in the first games compared with the two that followed. What do you like most about the first game?

I even had a hard time even finishing the first game, the controls felt stiff, the pacing was a bit off and the gameplay mechanics was not as polished. Really glad I did finish it and moved on to the second game in later the third. Consider both of them masterpieces. 

It’s mostly the story to be honest. Looks and controls do swing in 3’s favor but I feel like the story didn’t draw me in as well. I do need to replay them at some point to be fair about judging them. I haven’t actually played either game in close to a decade now. 

Though I've only played one game on this entire list, TLOU:P1 is a masterpiece. One of the greatest games ever made.

Lots of bangers there, but TLoU takes the cake.

Uncharted 1 is a good game, it's just that 2 and 3 are more refined both mechanically and technologically.
I'd give the original an 8/10 while the latter two are a 9/10.

I know a fair few folks found 3 to be lacking, but I thought it was terrific, just not quite as tightly constructed as 2, which is the highpoint of the series and one of the very best games of that generation.

First of all, anyone who says a game is the best "objectively" is talking nonesense, because these opinions,
even if a vast majority or players or magazines or ... agree, remain 100% subjective and are never objective.

As far as I am concerned, I view none of the listed games as the (subjectively) best. My pick for the subjectively best game is