konnichiwa said:
Ofcourse people don't want a police state but something has to happen. I mean their are people who wake up and are glad they had no scam call the last few days but have those annoying spam emails tho, does reporting those help? It feels useless but you keep on doing it, they go outside and bring something with them pepper spray or something else, they check if the inside home camera and doorcam is working. Then they bring the child to school, sure you wish the child who is 10 can go alone but the streets are not safe. On your way you can cleary see some people dealing drugs...do you or the other hundreds of drivers report it? Ofcourse not because the police knows this happens but they barely do anything.  Kids are at school and you finally park the car close to work, you see some addicts on the street, 10 years ago you would not see this but got normalized to it and you don't even want to think how they get money to buy their shit....  you arrive at the shop and say hi to the new extra hire security guard, clients then start complaining about how much stuff is now locked behind glass but you had to do it because so much stuff gets stolen, sometimes the thieves get caught but would return the day after and this is the only solution and it makes you angry.... Plenty of foreign tourists who went to USA, San Franciso, Seattle, Portland, NY, DC and so on will say they had a nice time but also that they are shocked by the homeless camps, drug addicts on the street, security measures in shops, Paris or London are not doing well either but it is a totally different level in some USA states/cities. |
More policing certainly isn't going to fix any of that.
Yeah something needs to change, but locking even more people up is not the answer.
Social programs reduce drug use, homelessness, larceny etc and those are only getting slashed by Trump.
Higher minimum wages, more affordable housing, universal healthcare will stop people losing everything and ending up on the street.
Better care for people with mental issues, ptsd will keep more people from ending up wandering the streets.
I've toured the USA in the 80s and 90s. We never felt unsafe, well San Francisco felt a bit grim after dark. More for the contradiction than all the homeless out on the streets, same in LA.
What we were 'shocked' by was the police messaging "It's the law". Very different from what we were used to. In Europe signs on the road were promoting safety, in Belgium even using humor to combat speeding etc. For example new interactive signs:

In the USA it was all "It's the law" on signs.

It's a different mindset.
For the homeless issues, some states are doing better than others
https://americaninequality.substack.com/p/homelessness-and-inequality-2024
And ofcourse, first comment is:
Crazy idea: maybe we shouldn’t let millions of homeless illegal immigrants walk across the border? James Madison high school in nyc just forced students into remote learning because they housed thousands of migrants.
In the article
While the influx of immigrants has led to some of the increase in homelessness, it has not been a leading cause as many pundits would lead us to believe. Instead, researchers at UC San Francisco conducted the largest survey of homeless people in the last 25 years and found that the leading cause was housing affordability. The overwhelming majority of the homeless population in California, for example, consisted of locals, with 90% of them losing their homes in the regions where they had already resided.
As long as people keep blaming immigration instead of inequality and lack of affordable housing, they're only playing into the hands of the billionaire class that want you to believe more policing is the way to go...
In the 80s we were far less worried about crime and safety, even though it was much more unsafe than today...
https://letgrow.org/crime-statistics/
If for some strange reason you WANTED your child to be kidnapped by a stranger, how long would you have to keep them outside, unattended, for this to be statistically likely to happen?
750,000 years.
...
“The frightening crime increase that began in 2020 is looking more and more like a passing phenomenon and not a continuing national disaster like the crime wave of the late 1960s through early 1990s.”
Violent-crime rate in 2023 was near its lowest level in more than 50 years, crime analyst Jeff Asher wrote for his newsletter. Source: NYTimes piece.
Big point: The murder rate today is actually lower today than it was in the ’90s — even with the crime increase of the COVID era.
Murder has declined substantially in the U.S. since the early 1990s, although increases occurred in 2005 and 2006, and again in 2015 and 2016. In 2021, the homicide rate for the cities studied was about half what it was for those cities 29 years ago (15 deaths per 100,000 residents in those cities versus 28 per 100,000 in 1993).
There's plenty work to be done, but crime etc is still way down from the 80s, 90s when we grew up without a care...
Reducing inequality and providing affordable housing is what needs to be done.