By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
 

How would you rate the '25 Developer Direct?

S 7 31.82%
 
A 8 36.36%
 
B 5 22.73%
 
C 1 4.55%
 
D 0 0%
 
F 1 4.55%
 
Total:22
Bizwas said:
Ryuu96 said:

Really stupid, tone-deaf from Kinda Funny to ask Ninja Theory's studio head a question about closures, he came on to proudly talk about his game then Gregg asks him a dumb ass question like that which made him uncomfortable, how the fuck is he meant to answer it?

Personally I think it is o.k. he asked that, I would actually have found it strange if he did not. I mean the studio closures were a serious shockwave sent through the xbox community, if the video game journalists (granted that is not necessarily how I would categorize Kinda Funny) should not just be microphone holders for the industry how should they ignore that in an interview with a studio head?

What is a true d*?!-move of Greg though is to ask it when they in advance have stated that they 100% will not ask it. But to me Dom Matthews seemed uncomfortable the entire interview, even before the question, and I would imagine that they are worried at Ninja Theory, and understandably so.

On how to answer it, I mean he could have said "self evidently we all heard about the closures and we feel for the colleagues who lost their jobs, but we just put the finishing touches on our game and our minds are on the imminent launch, we are so excited to get Saga out to the players and hear their feedback, so that is where our focus right now is." There is a little politician hidden in all of us.

Way I see it is that Greg can and should be asking these questions to Phil Spencer, Matt Booty, etc. These are the ones equipped to answer such questions, who should be held responsible and ultimately decide the fate of these studios and have the answers even if they bullshit us. There's nothing a Studio Head of a studio can do or say about closures which really offers anything of any substance.

He is on the show to excitedly promote his videogame that he has spent years creating, only to be reminded that he could lose his job and all his friends around him could lose his job, it almost feels like rubbing it in his face, it's not fair to him. Of course he is likely worried about Ninja Theory but we don't need to shove it in his face to remind him, let the man just enjoy his time promoting something he's proud of creating.

Your response is "fine" but ultimately it's a nothing answer to the question because what could he possibly even say? Lol. There's no real good or satisfying way to answer the question and Greg should have known that and all it does is cause unnecessary discomfort to the person being interviewed who has no responsibility over the closures or any real information that he could even divulge.



Around the Network

Yes, I thought of that.

A lot of my games won't be available, but it's better than nothing.

Even so, the comfort of the sofa and the console are currently preventing me from taking the plunge, but I think it's going to become inevitable.

What a waste.



VersusEvil said:

So if I’m understanding the complaints about ACS correctly, fighting mythical beings and ancient Japanese folklore is accurate but a black guy is TOO UNREALISTIC! They made a game for people like you, it’s called FF16.

For someone who's correctly called out DEI corpo shit before, I'm surprised you're using that strawman.  Also, Ubisoft are the ones who've previously voiced their passion for fusing historical accuracy & fantasy.  Haven't AC Origins, Odyssey, & Valhalla included interactive walking tours that double as World History 101 courses?

In that context, it's odd that a random retainer gets the starring role just on account of his race versus other actual Samurai legends of that era.  EDIT: This kinda feels like the Fable protag discussion all over again, as though it's discouraged to question why she looked kinda gross compared to the insanely hot actress.  

Last edited by coolbeans - on 16 May 2024

G2ThaUNiT said:
NightF0x73 said:

It's been a while since I last visited the forum, and my God, what a hell it is to be an Xbox gamer in 2024.

I can't believe and trust the brand anymore.
Unfortunately for me, I don't want to lose my +300 games, my progressions and my achievements.

I just don't know what to do.

Go full PC and start a Steam library?
Continue to support Xbox until an official third-party announcement without new hardware?

I'm too afraid that the next console (if it exists) will be abandoned by third-party publishers, given its unpopularity, of which I have no doubt.

If all games are released on PS6, why bother with this machine as a consumer.

The Xbox that made such an impression on me as a child with the 360 is definitely dead.

(I hate Nadella and Hood)

You don't have to 100% switch to Steam. There is still the Play Anywhere program. So if you do end up switching to PC, then go to the Xbox App that's built into Windows, and you'll see all get to play all your games that are part of Play Anywhere. Which isn't always just first-party. And of course, you still unlock all your achievements and add to your Gamescore as if you're still on Xbox. 

Yes, I thought of that.

A lot of my games won't be available, but it's better than nothing.

Even so, the comfort of the sofa and the console are currently preventing me from taking the plunge, but I think it's going to become inevitable.

What a waste.



KLXVER said:
Ryuu96 said:

Shōgun (TV Series 2024) - IMDb

Not sure what that has to do with anything. Are you saying it would be great to see a white person in the game because its great in the TV show or are you comparing a TV show about a specific story to this game?

I'm simply pointing out that right now there's a critically acclaimed, loved by the public and critics, TV Show featuring a white protagonist in feudal Japan who is loosely based on William Adams who became a samurai. Yasuke in Assassin's Creed is based on a real life person too called Yasuke, whether he was or wasn't a samurai is debatable but Assassin's Creed every single time has made changes to historical figures.

Nioh is loosely based on William Adams too.

Your response to Versus to me came across as you trying to bait him into looking hypocritical.



Around the Network
NightF0x73 said:
G2ThaUNiT said:

You don't have to 100% switch to Steam. There is still the Play Anywhere program. So if you do end up switching to PC, then go to the Xbox App that's built into Windows, and you'll see all get to play all your games that are part of Play Anywhere. Which isn't always just first-party. And of course, you still unlock all your achievements and add to your Gamescore as if you're still on Xbox. 

Yes, I thought of that.

A lot of my games won't be available, but it's better than nothing.

Even so, the comfort of the sofa and the console are currently preventing me from taking the plunge, but I think it's going to become inevitable.

What a waste.

MS and Valve have put that into consideration. Valve has for a long time actually had a"Big Picture Mode" but it was kinda trash for years, but then when the Steam Deck came out, they took the UI from that system and completely replaced Big Picture Mode with the Steam Deck UI. So it's a very couch friendly experience if you want to hook up your PC to your TV. 

MS has also recently been taking this into consideration, also because of Windows-based handheld PCs lol (handheld PC gaming is really a revolution these days) so they've added a "Compact Mode" to the Xbox App. It's just the flick of a button in the menu and you'll then be able to run both Steam and the Xbox App from the comfort of your couch. 

Last edited by G2ThaUNiT - on 16 May 2024

You called down the thunder, now reap the whirlwind

Ryuu96 said:
KLXVER said:

Not sure what that has to do with anything. Are you saying it would be great to see a white person in the game because its great in the TV show or are you comparing a TV show about a specific story to this game?

I'm simply pointing out that right now there's a critically acclaimed, loved by the public and critics, TV Show featuring a white protagonist in feudal Japan who is loosely based on William Adams who became a samurai. Yasuke in Assassin's Creed is based on a real life person too called Yasuke, whether he was or wasn't a samurai is debatable but Assassin's Creed every single time has made changes to historical figures.

Nioh is loosely based on William Adams too.

Your response to Versus to me came across as you trying to bait him into looking hypocritical.

Not baiting. Just wanted to find out where he stands on the subject. 

My stand is that I thought it was awesome that the main protagonist of Assassins Creed Valhalla was Norwegian. As I am Norwegian myself. 

Now Im not a huge Assassins Creed fan, but every protagonist of the franchise has been a native from the country that is being portrayed, right? Why couldnt the protagonist of a game set in Japan be Japanese?



coolbeans said:
VersusEvil said:

So if I’m understanding the complaints about ACS correctly, fighting mythical beings and ancient Japanese folklore is accurate but a black guy is TOO UNREALISTIC! They made a game for people like you, it’s called FF16.

For someone who's correctly called out DEI corpo shit before, I'm surprised you're using the that strawman.  Also, Ubisoft are the ones who've previously voiced their passion for fusing historical accuracy & fantasy.  Haven't AC Origins, Odyssey, & Valhalla included interactive walking tours that double as World History 101 courses?

In that context, it's odd that a random retainer gets the starring role just on account of his race versus other actual Samurai legends of that era.  EDIT: This kinda feels like the Fable protag discussion all over again, as though it's discouraged to question why she looked kinda gross compared to the insanely hot actress.  

Except this isn't DEI corpo shit, for Christ sake, every time you see a black man it doesn't automatically mean it's DEI, Japanese people themselves use Yasuke, Japanese author Yoshio Kurusu made a children's book about him, Takashi Okazaki's Afro Samurai is inspired by Yasuke, Koei Tecmo's Samurai Warriors 5 has Yasuke as a samurai, Nagoriyuki the samurai in Guilty Gear Strive is based on Yasuke!

Yasuke appears in the Japanese game Ni-Oh which is led by a frigging Irishman and nobody complained about that!

Leonidas I of Sparta wasn't a direct descendant of the Isu, Leonardo Da Vinci didn't chill with assassins, help create the hidden blade between all his other inventions and help an Assassin Guild, Pope Alexander VI wasn't a member of the Templar Order and fought in a crypt with a literal magical weapon. Leonidas didn't father both a boy and girl who went on to find Atlantis.

The Templar Order and Assassin Brotherhood doesn't exist ever. Adam and Eve! The Isu!

Where was the uproar when AC changed the historical accuracy of dozens of political figures since Assassin's Creed 1?

Rightfully you point out that Assassin's Creed mixes historical accuracy with fantasy. Yes, AC has had interactive walking tours that double as World History 101 courses, surely you see the difference between telling the history of some frigging buildings and the actual lore of the videogame itself? Take a history class and try to get through it by using only AC's lore itself and see how far you get.

"Yes, Queen Victoria worked with the Assassin Order to eliminate the Templar threat in 19th century London"

A*

Last edited by Ryuu96 - on 16 May 2024

G2ThaUNiT said:
NightF0x73 said:

Yes, I thought of that.

A lot of my games won't be available, but it's better than nothing.

Even so, the comfort of the sofa and the console are currently preventing me from taking the plunge, but I think it's going to become inevitable.

What a waste.

MS and Valve have put that into consideration. Valve has for a long time actually had a"Big Picture Mode" but it was kinda trash for years, but then when the Steam Deck came out, they took the UI from that system and completely replaced Big Picture Mode with the Steam Deck UI. So it's a very couch friendly experience if you want to hook up your PC to your TV. 

MS has also recently been taking this into consideration, also because of Windows-based handheld PCs lol (handheld PC gaming is really a revolution these days) so they've added a "Compact Mode" to the Xbox App. It's just the flick of a button in the menu and you'll then be able to run both Steam and the Xbox App from the comfort of your couch. 

Thanks for the info !

You're better at marketing than Microsoft :P



coolbeans said:
VersusEvil said:

So if I’m understanding the complaints about ACS correctly, fighting mythical beings and ancient Japanese folklore is accurate but a black guy is TOO UNREALISTIC! They made a game for people like you, it’s called FF16.

For someone who's correctly called out DEI corpo shit before, I'm surprised you're using that strawman.  Also, Ubisoft are the ones who've previously voiced their passion for fusing historical accuracy & fantasy.  Haven't AC Origins, Odyssey, & Valhalla included interactive walking tours that double as World History 101 courses?

In that context, it's odd that a random retainer gets the starring role just on account of his race versus other actual Samurai legends of that era.  EDIT: This kinda feels like the Fable protag discussion all over again, as though it's discouraged to question why she looked kinda gross compared to the insanely hot actress.  



Ride The Chariot | ‘25 Completed