My comments like this, MrStickball in italic
Just a few notes:
I DO believe the 360 will beat out the Wii this generation based on a few reasons:
Just to be 100% sure we are talking about USA only here, because honestly their is no way that xbox360 will sell more than Wii WW.
1. The primary reason is the fact that I believe year-wise, the 360 will live a longer life vs. the Wii. Even if the Wii does great, I think, at most, it'll get 5 years before a major overhaul. Right now, the 360 is looking at 6-7 years until a succuessor is launched, and MS has already indicated that they're not going to "Xbox" the 360 and kill the platform off. IMO, the Xbox, had it of recieved more support post-360 launch (like, actually have a factory produce the friggin' system), it would of sold an 500k systems in the US.
If xbox360 will get two years longer lifespan than Wii it should sell more, the problem I see is that no system that hasn't won early has stayed for a long time. If this would be true this time I don't know. The major problem I see for a really long support is it's weak performance in EU and Japan. In Sweden at least the price for the premium is almost the same as Wii, so it can't only be the price that is holding it back. I think that xbox360 could start selling more in EU if it got better hardware quality, myself is waiting for a new edition with better reability.
[EDIT] I failed to point out, xbox360 has already wasted one year of it supposely longer life than Wii. As I see it Wii will easily sell for 5 years before Wii 2 or whatever [/EDIT]
2. You can say "oh, SSB, SMG and MP3 are going to out-duel the holy 360 trinity of GTAIV, H3, and whatever #3 is between ME, Madden or Bioshock
, but the numbers just don't work.
Here should a lot of date be, that is totally correct but missing one important thing it was removed because I didn't want to make a to long post. The only thing wrong is to only cont one of the Zelda TP. As far as I know Zelda TP GC has sold more than one million.
I think the major problem with your argumetation is that you miss the number one game Nintendo will have and is already having: Wii Sport. The more I speak with people the more I understand the power of Wii Sport. Last friday another department at my work actualy spend a whole night playing Wii Sport against each other. Today at work we talked about Wii and I was shocked when I realised that for the casual crowd and mostly for women at my work Wii is equal to Wii Sport. The most intressting thing is that they seem to think it is really really fun. I personally belive that Wii Sport might have the power as a pack in as Super Mario once had.
Also, arguing how well a platformer will do vs. FPS, will reveal the fact that platformer sales have kind of been on the decline vs. FPS. One only can question how that'll effect SMG.
I agree but as stated before Mario, Metroid isn't what is going to drive the sales. Those games is only there to get the faithfull fans on board. Rest is pulled in by Wii Sport and other more simplistic games. Wii is going directly for the casual and I think they will strike gold. This is the important thing to note here: No plattform has ever won without the casual crowd.
I also think 2D plattforms is coming back, at least WW where insane sales of New Super Mario Bros has been seen.
Finally, I wonder: Has Nintendo even confirmed ALL 3 games are coming out this year?
Don't know but I do know that they aren't as important than the Wii X series.
For a final idea on this discussion:
Again I will point out one important thing. The power of new franshises, as Halo showed for xbox, a new title can be gold worth if it is made well and market well. Not only that it could be worth a LOT if it is market against some demographic that isn't playing or belived that they ever would buy a consol. Two games that comes to my mind is Singstar for PS2 and Nintendodogs for DS. I think that GC already showed that you couldn't realy on old titles to gain market share. You had to look at other markets to win and that I think is the most important thing here.
and one last thing, are you still reading
?
How much do we belive that xbox360 will increase it sales during the release of Halo3. The reason why I ask is simply because I do think Wii wont stop selling because of the realese of Halo3 nor GTA.