Just a few notes:
I DO believe the 360 will beat out the Wii this generation based on a few reasons:
1. The primary reason is the fact that I believe year-wise, the 360 will live a longer life vs. the Wii. Even if the Wii does great, I think, at most, it'll get 5 years before a major overhaul. Right now, the 360 is looking at 6-7 years until a succuessor is launched, and MS has already indicated that they're not going to "Xbox" the 360 and kill the platform off. IMO, the Xbox, had it of recieved more support post-360 launch (like, actually have a factory produce the friggin' system), it would of sold an 500k systems in the US.
2. You can say "oh, SSB, SMG and MP3 are going to out-duel the holy 360 trinity of GTAIV, H3, and whatever #3 is between ME, Madden or Bioshock
, but the numbers just don't work.
Examples from VGChartz:
Super Mario 64: 6,870,000 Units Sold (highest-selling Mario game in the US since Mario 3)
Smash Brothers MeLee: 4,060,000 Units Sold (highest selling GC game in the US)
Metroid Prime: 1,920,000 (Highest-selling MP game thus far)
Versus:
GTA:SA: 9,150,000 Units Sold
Halo 2: 6,110,000 Units Sold
Madden 07 (X360 version): 1,620,000 Units Sold
Now, showing these figures, the 360 has the higher precieved abilities in software. MP2 declined sales of the MP franchise by 1/2 (only sold 800k in the US), therefore, we cannot say that MP3 will outsell MP1, or what it'll do, so it's suspect.
SMG could get to SM64 levels, but again, it could be suspect: Zelda: TP has only sold 1.5m copies in the US, a level FAR lower than Zelda 64, the closest game for comparison in that catagory.
Here's the big issue:
Even as a Nintendo fanboy, you could argue that the best Nintendo can do is offer equal counter-programming to MS's top 3. I would argue this point, as H3/GTAIV have pretty strong sales going into it, and increasing sales in franchises, whereas SBM increased, and SMS decreased on GC.
Now, despite that, and giving Nintendo the benefit of the doubt, the issue is with second-tier software. What exactly does Nintendo have for confirmed, or very well likely other million sellers? Battallion Wars? Madden 08 maybe?
Here's the big issue I have with Nintendo really taking MS out this Christmas, the 360 has Stranglehold, Blue Dragon, Lost Odyssey, Army of Two, Madden 08, Mass Effect, Mercenaries 2 among their 3 and 4th quarter games. IMO, these games will most likely far outweigh Nintendo's second tier exclusive, or atleast important software.
Madden 08 will be the first true test of where Wii software will go. I fully expect for Madden 08's top seller to be on the 360 with above 2,000,000 unit sales. The Wii will be lucky to get 1m, if that.
Cjpie, your comparing the DS, which as sold 50m units, to a crappy GTA port to a PSP, which has sold half the units.
Also, if your wondering "how can a platformer get destroyed by an FPS", one only needs to start glancing over the way of Goldeneye 007. Yes, it didn't outsell SM64, but it's the highest selling 3rd party game for Nintendo in history.
Also, arguing how well a platformer will do vs. FPS, will reveal the fact that platformer sales have kind of been on the decline vs. FPS. One only can question how that'll effect SMG.
Finally, I wonder: Has Nintendo even confirmed ALL 3 games are coming out this year?