By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - XCloud or Stadia?

 

As a serious gamer, do you expect XCloud or Stadia to be more to your liking??

XCloud 18 46.15%
 
Stadia 2 5.13%
 
I still play text games over dial up 19 48.72%
 
Total:39
Barkley said:
vivster said:

They won't. Just like the PS5 they will only use the SSD to cache things. The main storage of minimum 1TB will still be an HDD. It's not feasible yet for consoles to include 1TB+ SSDs for everything.

I'm not sure how that's going to work though? Wouldn't game load times only improve after you've been playing the game for a while? The content still has to be copied from the HDD to the SSD after all. If they had a 256gb ssd I guess that would be enough room to hold the most often accessed data from ~2tb of installed games, otherwise if it was small only the most recently installed/played games could be partially cached on the ssd.

Depends on the size of the cache. I don't expect anything bigger than 128GB. It'll be non-volatile, so it will retain enough frequently used data for at least one game. After that it's just a question of algorithm which data to keep in there. I could think they will already copy data into the cache when you're installing the game. So you will instantly have the benefits of the faster load times. The SSD they're gonna use will also be faster than a regular mainstream SSD, so they'll get the best of both worlds.

It's a good solution that will work fine unless you're constantly switching between 5 huge games every 5 minutes, but nobody does that. It's a great solution for consoles because all of its processes are easily predictable and repetitive. It wouldn't work as well on PC where you have much more complex data streams.



If you demand respect or gratitude for your volunteer work, you're doing volunteering wrong.

Around the Network
vivster said:
Barkley said:

I'm not sure how that's going to work though? Wouldn't game load times only improve after you've been playing the game for a while? The content still has to be copied from the HDD to the SSD after all. If they had a 256gb ssd I guess that would be enough room to hold the most often accessed data from ~2tb of installed games, otherwise if it was small only the most recently installed/played games could be partially cached on the ssd.

Depends on the size of the cache. I don't expect anything bigger than 128GB. It'll be non-volatile, so it will retain enough frequently used data for at least one game. After that it's just a question of algorithm which data to keep in there. I could think they will already copy data into the cache when you're installing the game. So you will instantly have the benefits of the faster load times. The SSD they're gonna use will also be faster than a regular mainstream SSD, so they'll get the best of both worlds.

It's a good solution that will work fine unless you're constantly switching between 5 huge games every 5 minutes, but nobody does that. It's a great solution for consoles because all of its processes are easily predictable and repetitive. It wouldn't work as well on PC where you have much more complex data streams.

I'm excited to see how well it works. Ever since we moved to CD ROMs from cartridges, load times have been terrible. I guess we've gotten used to them, but I remember that I thought they were a huge step backwards when I first experienced them.  If the problem has been solved, or substantially improved, I think I've see that as a major step forward.



RolStoppable said:
VAMatt said:

I'm excited to see how well it works. Ever since we moved to CD ROMs from cartridges, load times have been terrible. I guess we've gotten used to them, but I remember that I thought they were a huge step backwards when I first experienced them.  If the problem has been solved, or substantially improved, I think I've see that as a major step forward.

This will probably be as much of a solution as mandatory installs to an HDD were on the PS4 and XB1, so it's first and foremost a measure to prevent loading times from getting much longer.

Way to crush my hopes and dreams, buddy.  

Seriously though, it is very important to keep them from getting worse.