I'll go with Skyrim. Such a massively important game that people are still playing even today.

Not by today's count.  

Then you must have heavily miscounted, because BotW is still winning by quite a large margin.

wow, wow...my reading comprehension was not up to par this morning.  It pats to pay attention to the entire sentence.  I thought (obviously very mistakingly) that his assertion was that Uncharted won if you added them up together.

Definitely some egg on my face and I'll step away from the keyboard until I've had some breakfast and a bit more energy for my brain.

BotW is just steamrolling. The game had the right impact on the industry that made others stop and think about the way to approach open worlds and exploration. Truly a masterpiece of its time.

Voted BOTW as the best from this list, but there are games from other years I'd rather have voted for that weren't listed.

Skyrim, easily. Next closest would be BOTW.

The rest, meh.