By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Movies & TV - J.K. Rowling finally addresses Johnny Depp's casting as Grindelwald in Fantastic Beasts franchise

SuperNova on 11 December 2017
Nem said:
SuperNova said:

So you had nothing to say about the multitude of questions I asked about your comments on the matter or any of the confirmed information I brought into the topic and proceed to answer in the most generalized and dumbed down manner possible, but I'm the one who is generalizing and dramatizing?

As for your comment itself, we have an entire justice system dedicated only to finding out and proving if a crime took place. We still see this system fail to provide victims with justice or even manage to convict the correct person for any given crime on a daily basis. This is clearly not very simple.

But you knew that.

I'm sad to see that you are not interested in actual intelligent discourse.  Have a nice day.

Good. Cause the topic is Depp and not the whole thing, wich i have no desire to talk about.

Depp is a good actor. If there is something unlawful he did, charges should be pressed and judged by the law. 

That has zero influence on wether he shows up in the movies and plays the character well. Quite honestly, that doesn't entitle anyone to try and make justice through their own hands. EVERYONE will lose in that world. You want harsher punishments, vote on the right politicians that share that vision. You are not and can never be the law. No one can. That isn't justice.

You were the one who bought Weistein and Moore and the general climate into it, not me.

I was just responding to your initial comment. If you had wanted to stay on Depp as a topic you should have done it and not posted apparently barely thought through commentary on the current social climate that you would like to not have adressed now.



Around the Network
Nem on 12 December 2017
SuperNova said:
Nem said:

Good. Cause the topic is Depp and not the whole thing, wich i have no desire to talk about.

Depp is a good actor. If there is something unlawful he did, charges should be pressed and judged by the law. 

That has zero influence on wether he shows up in the movies and plays the character well. Quite honestly, that doesn't entitle anyone to try and make justice through their own hands. EVERYONE will lose in that world. You want harsher punishments, vote on the right politicians that share that vision. You are not and can never be the law. No one can. That isn't justice.

You were the one who bought Weistein and Moore and the general climate into it, not me.

I was just responding to your initial comment. If you had wanted to stay on Depp as a topic you should have done it and not posted apparently barely thought through commentary on the current social climate that you would like to not have adressed now.

Yeah because my point was that all of that is getting out of hand and the topic is silly with the Depp thing.

Him doing the film is the natural thing to happen, unless he committed a crime and is in Jail on at least being prosecuted.

As the other poster said, the era of witch hunts is over. Even JK Rowling can see past it, wich is good. Theres things worth getting riled for and things that aren't. If you get riled up over all of them, it becomes the norm and the really serious ones don't get due atention.