Nem said:
They are nothing like cut-scenes. What are you on about? They are portion of the game when the story or level comes to a climax and mixes up things for you. Where you have to discover a pattern or weak spot or dodge powerful attacks. It makes you think and strategise. It's great. Would you rather some more of the same enemies just pop up again with bigger life bars or something? Ain't that super lazy and boring? Now, of course, bad games are bad games. If a game makes a bad boss fight its probably a bad game to begin with. I don't think it's the boss fight that will make it so. I don't agree with many of those examples btw. I didn't play any of those except Uncharted 2, and i thought the final boss was good. For example TLOU had no final boss when the boss was right there. Clearly a rushed and incomplete game that left me unsatisfied. If you aren't willing to change things, your game becomes predictable,boring and unsatisfying. You don't get that sense of accomplishment you'd usually get. I still remember going: What? That was it? It's over? Completely unsatisfied. I felt robbed. |
By being like cut scenes I meant provoking the same set of emotions in me like cutscenese, dread and disengagement.
I loved the ending of TloU, perfect way to end a game, played it 3 times. Uncharted 4, horrible last few levels and ending, traded it in. The first 10 levels or so were excellent but the end ruined it.
Boss battles are usually very restrictive. They ruined Deus Ex HR, I didn't even feel like getting the sequel anymore. The rest of the game was excellent and let me strategise and play the way I wanted to. Boss fight force you to play them like a qte, find the right time / place to hit, just wait and dodge until then, boring.
Anyway I never get a sense of accomplishment from beating a boss, just relief that's over with and look for a save point asap so I can continue with playing the game.
I don't mind hard battles though. I usually fight normal enemies way above my level in RPGs, much more fun than a restrictive boss battles and a lot more challenging. The best fight I remember are early fights against Lynels in BotW, going back to the start dungeon early in Dark Souls for a long half hour fight dodging between pillars against some of the enemies there or taking on high level monster hunts in TW3. Much better than any put in your way boss battle.
