First thread?
I was reluctant to try This War Of Mine. I thought it sounded pretentious, the "game-play" looked dull, and I normally pass on anything side-scrolling. However, I kept reading atypical words of praise for it and a Steam sale made me jump. I ended up loving it and putting a ton of hours into it.
On a related side-scrolling note, I decided to try a Rayman game on Vita. It also had a bunch of praise and I was thinking that maybe I should give platformers another chance. I'd grown sick of them years ago but it had been forever since I'd played one. I ended up remembering all the things I dislike about the genre and quit after a few levels. At least I now know for sure and no future game will tempt me.