By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Website Topics - The Moderator Thread

Kerotan said:
Azuren said:

What tyranny?

It's a joke 

What joke?



Watch me stream games and hunt trophies on my Twitch channel!

Check out my Twitch Channel!:

www.twitch.tv/AzurenGames

Around the Network
Azuren said:
Aeolus451 said:
What is this house of El stuff?

What do you mean?

Well, why do you guys have it as a tag on your profile pics and why are you guys talking about it.



Aeolus451 said:
Azuren said:

What do you mean?

Well, why do you guys have it as a tag on your profile pics and why are you guys talking about it.

I'm not sure I understand.



Watch me stream games and hunt trophies on my Twitch channel!

Check out my Twitch Channel!:

www.twitch.tv/AzurenGames

Lawlight said:
StarDoor said:

How convenient that every single one of your assumptions works into a narrative that paints Sony's Japanese performance in the best possible light and Nintendo's Japanese performance in the worst, while at the same time allowing you to expect a worldwide decline for the Switch. Truly amazing.

According to you:

1.) Console sales are still in decline in Japan -> Therefore, it would be impressive for PS4 to merely match PS3 in Japan
2.) Handheld sales are stable in Japan -> Therefore, it's obvious that the Switch could reach 20 million in Japan, and its current sales are unimpressive
3.) Handheld sales are still in decline in the west -> Therefore, the Switch will sell less worldwide than the 3DS

1 and 2 make no sense when put together: An obvious double standard. Apparently, 27 million PS2+GCN going to 23 million PS3+Wii is enough to suggest a permanent decline that lasts into the eighth generation, but 53 million PSP+DS to 29 million 3DS+Vita suggests stability.

3 is veritably false, since we have five months of NPD data and Nintendo's own shipment numbers that show how the Switch is much more popular than the 3DS in the west. The Switch is selling faster at $300 than the 3DS did at $170. The 3DS was never sold out in the US, yet the Switch is still sold out five months later with higher shipment numbers. Rational observers would conclude that the supposed "decline" was in large part because the 3DS was simply an unappealing product to westerners.

There are no assumptions in my post - only facts and trends based on facts. It's not my fault if the numbers paints Sony's Japanese performance in a positive light.

1 & 2 make perfect sense:

The decline doesn't look as bad from PS2+GCN to PS3+Wii because the Wii overperformed by selling to the non-gaming market. That market isn't there anymore. Look at the PS consoles sales trend in Japan - going from selling 23M to 10M. When it comes to the core console gaming audience, the decline has been steep. Just look at the WiiU's number - it was well supported by Nintendo and yet its sales dropped from the GC numbers.

And yes, handheld gaming is stable in Japan as the 3DS is the 3rd best selling system in Japan. It outsold the PSP after all. And this is another case where you cannot just compare total numbers - the DS, like the Wii, temporarily expanded the market while, at the same time, the Vita was never truly supported by Sony, especially in Japan.

3 is verifiably true. The 3DS is the first handheld to have sold more in Japan that any of the other western regions. Imagine that a system selling more in Japan than in the Europe or the US. You also cannot use just NPD as we're talking about both Europe and the US. You're also forgetting that the Switch is not selling in the west as a handheld but as a console.

And FYI selling out means nothing without numbers. I guess we'll have to wait for a few more years to show who's right and who's wrong.

1) PS3 also declined worldwide: 158 million to 87 million. Do you think that was because the worldwide console market shrank? No, it's because the PS3 library was less appealing than the PS2 library to westerners, and doubly so for Japan. And as a side note, Japan accounted for a higher percentage of Wii U sales than GameCube sales, so that is completely spurious.

2) How is the 3DS outselling the PSP indicative of the market being stable? The 3DS+Vita is 29 million, and the PSP is 20 million. Are you arguing that only 9 million DS sales went to the core market, and Nintendo's core audience actually grew in Japan by 15 million from DS to 3DS? This is ludicrous, especially as the Game Boy sold 33 million in Japan, just as much as the DS. Was the GB also a temporary expansion?

You say that the Vita's poor sales are because it was never truly supported by Sony, which means that you agree that a console's library has an impact on its sales. This further deconstructs your argument about a severe decline in the core console gaming audience, seeing that you explain away a decline in the handheld market by talking about the Vita's lack of support, but ignore any such logic for other declines. Obviously the PS3 would have poor sales relative to previous PS consoles: Gen 7 saw a majority of Japanese developers go bankrupt or take a nosedive in quality.

3) The handheld market is certainly not declining anymore, given that the Switch is selling better than the 3DS. It certainly declined from the DS to the 3DS, but that generation is over. If you want to talk about Europe, the Switch is still doing better there. The 3DS shipped 400k in Europe and RoW in its second quarter, while the Switch shipped 690k. Of course, Europe really doesn't even matter considering the Switch's performance in the Americas: 110k versus 750k during its second quarter. Despite your strange assertions, we do, in fact, have numbers. The Switch is selling out with a vastly larger amount of stock than the 3DS.

By the way...

Lawlight said:

How is the bar ridiculously low when the bar is close to the best selling console of last generation in Japan has sold 12M with the PS3 selling 10M? We've told you multiple times that console sales are in decline in Japan but you chose to compare the PS4 sales to sales of consoles from 2 generations ago.

Handhel market is in decline worldwide but it is steady in Japan. As for why I said you shouldn't expect very high sales for the Switch, it is because Nintendo's console sales have been declining worldwide while their handheld sales have been declining in the west. Please keep that in mind before suggesting that I switch narrative.

Would you look at that. Can anyone say "narrative switch"? You literally just said that the Switch won't do well in the west because of the decline of handhelds, but now you're explaining away its success in the west because it's selling as a home console.



RolStoppable said:
Over 60 new posts since I've last seen this thread and the majority was rubbish. This thread is in dire need of mods who still know what this thread is supposed to be about. It's not about rampant spamming and throwing around baseless accusations.

Thank God we have a fake mod with an ego problem to set us straight. Is a little bit of fun cutting into your soapbox time?



Around the Network
RolStoppable said:
Over 60 new posts since I've last seen this thread and the majority was rubbish. This thread is in dire need of mods who still know what this thread is supposed to be about. It's not about rampant spamming and throwing around baseless accusations.

Some are goofing off and some are discussing the topics that get them moderated. What's the big deal?



RavenXtra said:
RolStoppable said:
Over 60 new posts since I've last seen this thread and the majority was rubbish. This thread is in dire need of mods who still know what this thread is supposed to be about. It's not about rampant spamming and throwing around baseless accusations.

Thank God we have a fake mod with an ego problem to set us straight. Is a little bit of fun cutting into your soapbox time?

Lol that cracked me up. 

 

@Bristow bingo! 



Nautilus said:
vivster said:

While we're on the topic of people continuously downplaying and attacking a certain platform while uptalking their own.

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=231178

Time for someone new to get the Kerotan treatment. This hate on PC has been going on for a while and he has been banned quite a few times by now. Why not let him taste the banhammer from now on at the slightest trace of baiting? It's even made easy by the fact that the thead title is a complete lie and specifically constructed to bait people.

edit: Another recent thread that only exists to take shots at Microsoft.

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=231138

 

I could dig up more but he made his user profile conveniently unavailable.

I didnt really take a long look at these threads Vivvy, but I mean, you are not exactly innocent in this game of downplaying other consoles, especially Nintendo.

But I downplay everything. I'm not a fanboy of a single platform. See, my motive is just to disrupt circle jerks while fanboy's motive is to sell more consoles for their brand overlords.

I'm just so often in Nintendo threads because that's simply the most threads in this forum and the easiest to either be created as or devolve into a circle jerk. I'm just trying to help to make this forum a nicer place :(



If you demand respect or gratitude for your volunteer work, you're doing volunteering wrong.

StarDoor said:
Lawlight said:

There are no assumptions in my post - only facts and trends based on facts. It's not my fault if the numbers paints Sony's Japanese performance in a positive light.

1 & 2 make perfect sense:

The decline doesn't look as bad from PS2+GCN to PS3+Wii because the Wii overperformed by selling to the non-gaming market. That market isn't there anymore. Look at the PS consoles sales trend in Japan - going from selling 23M to 10M. When it comes to the core console gaming audience, the decline has been steep. Just look at the WiiU's number - it was well supported by Nintendo and yet its sales dropped from the GC numbers.

And yes, handheld gaming is stable in Japan as the 3DS is the 3rd best selling system in Japan. It outsold the PSP after all. And this is another case where you cannot just compare total numbers - the DS, like the Wii, temporarily expanded the market while, at the same time, the Vita was never truly supported by Sony, especially in Japan.

3 is verifiably true. The 3DS is the first handheld to have sold more in Japan that any of the other western regions. Imagine that a system selling more in Japan than in the Europe or the US. You also cannot use just NPD as we're talking about both Europe and the US. You're also forgetting that the Switch is not selling in the west as a handheld but as a console.

And FYI selling out means nothing without numbers. I guess we'll have to wait for a few more years to show who's right and who's wrong.

1) PS3 also declined worldwide: 158 million to 87 million. Do you think that was because the worldwide console market shrank? No, it's because the PS3 library was less appealing than the PS2 library to westerners, and doubly so for Japan. And as a side note, Japan accounted for a higher percentage of Wii U sales than GameCube sales, so that is completely spurious.

2) How is the 3DS outselling the PSP indicative of the market being stable? The 3DS+Vita is 29 million, and the PSP is 20 million. Are you arguing that only 9 million DS sales went to the core market, and Nintendo's core audience actually grew in Japan by 15 million from DS to 3DS? This is ludicrous, especially as the Game Boy sold 33 million in Japan, just as much as the DS. Was the GB also a temporary expansion?

You say that the Vita's poor sales are because it was never truly supported by Sony, which means that you agree that a console's library has an impact on its sales. This further deconstructs your argument about a severe decline in the core console gaming audience, seeing that you explain away a decline in the handheld market by talking about the Vita's lack of support, but ignore any such logic for other declines. Obviously the PS3 would have poor sales relative to previous PS consoles: Gen 7 saw a majority of Japanese developers go bankrupt or take a nosedive in quality.

3) The handheld market is certainly not declining anymore, given that the Switch is selling better than the 3DS. It certainly declined from the DS to the 3DS, but that generation is over. If you want to talk about Europe, the Switch is still doing better there. The 3DS shipped 400k in Europe and RoW in its second quarter, while the Switch shipped 690k. Of course, Europe really doesn't even matter considering the Switch's performance in the Americas: 110k versus 750k during its second quarter. Despite your strange assertions, we do, in fact, have numbers. The Switch is selling out with a vastly larger amount of stock than the 3DS.

By the way...

Lawlight said:

How is the bar ridiculously low when the bar is close to the best selling console of last generation in Japan has sold 12M with the PS3 selling 10M? We've told you multiple times that console sales are in decline in Japan but you chose to compare the PS4 sales to sales of consoles from 2 generations ago.

Handhel market is in decline worldwide but it is steady in Japan. As for why I said you shouldn't expect very high sales for the Switch, it is because Nintendo's console sales have been declining worldwide while their handheld sales have been declining in the west. Please keep that in mind before suggesting that I switch narrative.

Would you look at that. Can anyone say "narrative switch"? You literally just said that the Switch won't do well in the west because of the decline of handhelds, but now you're explaining away its success in the west because it's selling as a home console.

1. No. It was because the PS3 was super expensive, launched 1 year after the 360 and never reached mass market price. And yet it still came relatively close to the PS1. I don't see why you're forgetting how much of the market share the 360 took away from the PS3.

 

2. You're not listening when I said that Sony didn't support the Vita so I don't see why you're adding the 3DS sales to the Vita one to show that the handheld market isn't stable in Japan. Sony doesn't care about the handheld market. As for the GB, it was the first true handheld and those numbers include both the GB and the GBC numbers. Why not use the GBA sales to compare with the 3DS? The 3DS sold better than the GBA in Japan but way less in the west.

And yes, a console library does impact its sales. You say that a lot of devs went bankrupt last gen which is why the PS3 wasn't well supported which led to lower console sales. So how is that going to change this gen? We've seen that the PS4 is getting massive support from devs so why aren't console sales going way up? Let me tell you why - it's because the console market is much smaller now.

 

3. We only have numbers for 2 quarters and guess what? The Switch isn't leading by much - 4.7M vs 4.32M. For all it's super slow start, the 3DS isn't far behind the Switch which is being supported right out of the gate with Nintendo's most popular franchises. How long do you think the Switch will keep ahead? And that's not even factoring the WiiU numbers.

 

As for your last point, another's false equivalence from you. I said the Switch won't be very high - not that it won't do relatively well. It will be a decline for Nintendo. My narrative still the same. Nintendo's console sales declining worldwide doesn't mean that it'll sell 0 in the west. It means that worldwide, Nintendo's consoles sales are declining. Similarly, handheld sales declining in the west does not mean thtat it'll sell 0 in the west. Japan will hold up Switch sales up. The combination of the remaining handheld fans and the remaining potential buyers of a Nintendo console will hold up the Switch sales (will still be down) but remember this is due to the combination of the platforms.

 

I mean do you think Nintendo combined handheld and console and lost 1 pillar for fun? As I said, we will see in a few years but how many units do you think the Switch will sell overall.



Welp, this thread is getting out of hand.

Someone's going to have to Rol out some bans