Does this mean that I can call people trolls and obnoxious pricks now without being moderated? If yes, I completely support Talon's behavior.
Does this mean that I can call people trolls and obnoxious pricks now without being moderated? If yes, I completely support Talon's behavior.
We shouldn't be avoiding a moderation on TalonMan because he's site a site admin.
We should be avoiding a moderation on TalonMan because common sense should be at the middle of any decision a mod team makes. I've been a long time advocate of trimming down our rule set and moving to a more common sense model of moderation, and I've been saying for a long time that our current rule set can be condensed down to a simple phrase - "Don't be a dick".
If you're being a dick, don't be surprised to see people call you out on being a dick. Also don't be surprised to see the mod team turn a blind eye to someone calling you a dick from time to time.
![]()
A negative and baiting post shouldn't be reacted to, but rather, reported to the mod team and move along
NintenDomination [May 2015 - July 2017]

- Official VGChartz Tutorial Thread -
NintenDomination [2015/05/19 - 2017/07/02]
Here lies the hidden threads.
| |
Nintendo Metascore | Official NintenDomination | VGC Tutorial Thread
| Best and Worst of Miiverse | Manga Discussion Thead |
[3DS] Winter Playtimes [Wii U]
| Carl2291 said: We shouldn't be avoiding a moderation on TalonMan because he's site a site admin. We should be avoiding a moderation on TalonMan because common sense should be at the middle of any decision a mod team makes. I've been a long time advocate of trimming down our rule set and moving to a more common sense model of moderation, and I've been saying for a long time that our current rule set can be condensed down to a simple phrase - "Don't be a dick". If you're being a dick, don't be surprised to see people call you out on being a dick. Also don't be surprised to see the mod team turn a blind eye to someone calling you a dick from time to time. |
I just want to voice my support for this idea. Some people get away with some ridiculous stuff just because it's not explicitly forbidden in the rules. I still think the discussion culture here is excellent compared to many other sites, but there's always room for improvement.
| Carl2291 said: We shouldn't be avoiding a moderation on TalonMan because he's site a site admin. We should be avoiding a moderation on TalonMan because common sense should be at the middle of any decision a mod team makes. I've been a long time advocate of trimming down our rule set and moving to a more common sense model of moderation, and I've been saying for a long time that our current rule set can be condensed down to a simple phrase - "Don't be a dick". If you're being a dick, don't be surprised to see people call you out on being a dick. Also don't be surprised to see the mod team turn a blind eye to someone calling you a dick from time to time. |
I just wish that logic applied to everyone. I'm pretty sure if I told someone they're being a dick no matter who id get moderated.
Kerotan said:
I just wish that logic applied to everyone. I'm pretty sure if I told someone they're being a dick no matter who id get moderated. |
I think Talon was given admin powers directly from ioi though, and not the mod team, so they can't really do anything about it.
TalonMan said:
Brett gave me access to the server - that's all. I gave myself the other tags (site admin, gamedb, mod, etc.) so I could see the functionality and work with it - no more, no less. Either that, or I run through all the code and fix every "if moderator" to be "if moderator or siteadmin" - but I think my time could be spent better on other things. I'm not forcing my will on anyone around here - if the mod team feels I've stepped over some line, so be it. This whole thing reminds of grammar school with my daughter - the one girl continues to needle my daughter until she finally reacts. Once she does react, the instigator runs off to get a teacher so she can pretend as though she's the victim... It's absurd and childish. |
I want you here
I think actually that the Project Managers idea is a good thing, because it means you won't have to deal with things like this directly, we can deal with it ourselves instead.
| TalonMan said: This whole thing reminds of grammar school with my daughter - the one girl continues to needle my daughter until she finally reacts. Once she does react, the instigator runs off to get a teacher so she can pretend as though she's the victim... It's absurd and childish. |
Welcome to our lives 
![]()
VGPolyglot said:
I think Talon was given admin powers directly from ioi though, and not the mod team, so they can't really do anything about it. |
Ok so he's above the law. Sanctioned by Lord iOS himself so im ok with this. Talon you can hsve my babies .
Kerotan said:
Ok so he's above the law. Sanctioned by Lord iOS himself so im ok with this. Talon you can hsve my babies . |
Your sarcasm doesn't amuse me.