By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Nintendo Shuts Down Another Pokemon Fan Project

Ka-pi96 said:
Hapuc12 said:

No dude just no when it comes to fanmade games with the same name of the IP.

Sure some companies allow modding most of them don't,i know bethesda and Cd Project Red allow modding maybe few more most of them don't,hell even Rockstar doesn't allow modding.

But fanmade games based on protected IP they don't allow that,not one company allows that maybe a fangame based on the title but with different name and almost everything else,except gameplay and few other elements,like that game based on Shadow of Collosus that's has been on Kickstarter.

I`m not sure they can even do anything about modding. There`s only a few that make modding easy, sure. But try and name a single one that actually doesn`t allow it? And no, not even Rockstar stop mods... http://www.moddb.com/games/grand-theft-auto-v/mods

Everyone loves to talk about how mods are great.  I have never used mods.  The most I ever did was play user made scenarios in Civ3.  Can mods make games better?  I'm sure but I really don't see the big fuss about mods.  I've never been like you know what... A mod could totally make this game better.  Probably because I never gave a shit about mods to begin with.



Around the Network

There are many pokemon fan games that dont get caught cause they advertise it in secret on their fan creation forums. These creators need to stop coming out publicly and announcing their project.

Didn't they just sell over 5 million copies with Sun/Moon? They have nothing to protect lol



Ka-pi96 said:
Hapuc12 said:

No dude just no when it comes to fanmade games with the same name of the IP.

Sure some companies allow modding most of them don't,i know bethesda and Cd Project Red allow modding maybe few more most of them don't,hell even Rockstar doesn't allow modding.

But fanmade games based on protected IP they don't allow that,not one company allows that maybe a fangame based on the title but with different name and almost everything else,except gameplay and few other elements,like that game based on Shadow of Collosus that's has been on Kickstarter.

I`m not sure they can even do anything about modding. There`s only a few that make modding easy, sure. But try and name a single one that actually doesn`t allow it? And no, not even Rockstar stop mods... http://www.moddb.com/games/grand-theft-auto-v/mods

No no i didn't say supporting,most of them like you said can't do anything about it,but Rockstar as rockstar doesn't support modding,like they don't give engine or creation kit as much as i'm aware of to the players to mod,i never said the game isn't being modded but Rockstar is anti modding that's all.



Makes me wonder if my upcoming game Pikimon will be closed down by Nintendo. It features colourful characters that battle each other using a points based system.



sethnintendo said:

boo fucking hoo. Who fucking cares. Cry me a river.  Go make something original or don't share it on the internet.

Tbh i'm with you on that instead wasting 8-9 years like they did with with this game they could have created something amazing like those dudes with owlboy,hell even a game like undertale if they were going for pokemon style route.



Around the Network
merman said:
the thing is Nintendo are just so so far out of touch with reality at the moment. i understand being smart with your property but Nintendo just don't get the internet at all. its the same where if you tubers put there content in a video it can be removed for copyright even though its free publicity for that game in the first place.

but yeh, who needs fans

You also seem out of touch, Nintendo doesn't remove the content, it removes the monotization of the content, that is their current policy in that regard. Also this is protecting their trademark and a lot more developers do this.  People don't really seem to understand how trademark protection works, because it is simple you don't protect it, you lose it. You lose it, anyone can make anything based on that trademark. 

Could nintendo have better approach to fan made project, possibly, but honestly when it comes to Pokemon, they are dime a dozen. I rather they protect the IP than working with fan made developers. Now things like Metroid project, I wish they worked with the developer, since Nintendo has no interest. 

One thing it is to be inspired by Pokemon, another thing is to use Pokemon in the title of your game or possible assets of Pokemon Franchise.  

Also a lot of people bringing up modding in regards to fan made content, Nintendo exists in a closed console space, not really open PC space. 



 

After all those years of hard work... 🤕



Proud to be the first cool Nintendo fan ever

Number ONE Zelda fan in the Universe

DKCTF didn't move consoles

Prediction: No Zelda HD for Wii U, quietly moved to the succesor

Predictions for Nintendo NX and Mobile




                                                                                     

What's the big deal? Of course Nintendo is going to shut it down. Any sane company would. If I open a restaurant and called it "McDonald's" and started giving away burgers there for free, I reckon I'll be getting a call from McDonald's pretty soon. And whoever would suggest that I'm "helping" McDonald's by growing the fanbase is a fool, I'm sorry. No, what I'm doing is hurting McDonald's because why would people continue to pay money to eat at McDonald's when they can get the same taste from my shop for free?



I don't really get why people continue to share info on their fan games puplicly. Some fan games have a tendency to be shut down by the IP owners, depending on what it is. I recall a few Chrono Trigger games suffered the same fate some time back, so it's probably not going to change suddenly. Fan creators really outta keep their fan games a secret, and do so with their releases.

It sucks that it happens, and I wish it wouldn't, but it happens, and not everyone is cool with making fan games of their games.



 

              

Dance my pretties!

The Official Art Thread      -      The Official Manga Thread      -      The Official Starbound Thread