I agree and disagree with Nolan North. Performance of every creative person does matter and it only serves the interests of publishers and corporate empires for different "factions" of creative people to be fighting among themselves about who deserves more. THEY ALL DESERVE MORE. I wish people would get that trough their thick skulls, especially the actors, designers and developers who are opposing this. Ultimately, if the voice actors get a better deal this can flow through in some way to the other artists in the game industry.
How is what North says about if they didn't do their work his job wouldn't exist differ to moves, TV and theatre. Acting jobs in any medium only exists because other people have put in a huge amount of work before the actors get to do their performance. The part of Gollum in LOTR would not exist if Tolkien had not written the book, Peter Jackson hadn't convinced a studio to produce the movie, and he hadn't written a script that was good enough to be turned into a film, and all the SFX people hadn't done a brilliant job doing Gollum's animation. Yet Andy Serkis still gets royalties for his performance as Gollum.
All the voice actors in the Disney animated movies get royalties for their voice work, that is 100% the same work as the voice actors in video games. 100% the same, they stand in a studio and read the lines.
This isn't an argument about whether game VAs should get more. It's an argument about whether game VAs should get the same sort of deal as movie and TV actors. And the answer is absolutely yes they should get the same sort of deal.
Should designers and developers get a better deal? Damned right the should. And I hope they band together and demand it.
I've lost a bit of respect for Nolan North since he seems to suffer from a lack of vision even though he was well intentioned by acknowledging the amazing and essential work the other creative people do.
Go ahead Naught Dog, make TLOU and Uncharted with computer generated "Stephen Hawking" vocals. See how that goes down. Or how about have no voices and just text dialogue? Yeah, no. Quality voice work is important in many video games it is part of the experience, and poor voice work lowers the quality of the experience.
“The fundamental cause of the trouble is that in the modern world the stupid are cocksure while the intelligent are full of doubt.” - Bertrand Russell
"When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace."
Jimi Hendrix