onionberry said:
JEMC said:
You're the one that used those figures and then compared them with the Switch .
And sure, Nvidia is more efficient than AMD, but we're talking about a device that will consume 15, maybe up to 20W in a best case scenario while the competing machines (PS4 Slim & XboxOne S) use more than 3x that power and are build in the same manufacturing process. Not even Nvidia is that efficient.
And let's not forget that, while Maxwell or Pascal can do certain tasks better than AMD's Tahiti, the latest can also do certain tasks better than what Nvidia has.
|
all i'm trying to say is, we don't have the specs, as a matter of fact we don't have the actual architecture, could be pascal could be volta and we don't know the optimization. So the "switch is weak and underpowered" statement is not fair just yet, weaker than the ps4 or xbox, maybe, but how weak? also, we are talking about a tablet here (form factor and ignoring the dock) and that's other thing, the dock could have a high performance mode or something like that.
|
Please tell me that you just used Volta as an example, because the chances of Nintendo using Volta architecture on the Switch is not even zero but negative. Maxwell at worst or Pascal at best, those are the two chances, not anyone else.
On the calling the Switch weak and underpowered, something that I haven't done, I agree that isn't fair, but given that the device also replaces the WiiU and is designed in part to work as a home console, comparing it to the current competition in the home console space is not unfair, and it's even needed when it comes to discussing third party support.
Lastly, about the dock providing a high performance boost, that idea is only backed by the internet speculation (that believes that having a dock that doesn't provide extra performance is silly) against what Nintendo said after the teaser reveal: "The main function of the Nintendo Switch Dock is to provide an output to the TV, as well as charging and providing power to the system." (via IGN). Given that I don't remember any tweet or anything from Rogers or any other insider saying otherwise (note that I don't say that they don't exist, only that I don't remember them), I'll trust Nintendo more than "the internet".
Miyamotoo said:
JEMC said:
You're the one that used those figures and then compared them with the Switch .
And sure, Nvidia is more efficient than AMD, but we're talking about a device that will consume 15, maybe up to 20W in a best case scenario while the competing machines (PS4 Slim & XboxOne S) use more than 3x that power and are build in the same manufacturing process. Not even Nvidia is that efficient.
And let's not forget that, while Maxwell or Pascal can do certain tasks better than AMD's Tahiti, the latest can also do certain tasks better than what Nvidia has.
|
Just have on mind that PS4Slim/XB1s have AMD tech from 2012, while Switch has Nvidia tech most likely from 2016, so comparing consumptions of different tech from different period doesn't make too much sense. Also Switch can easily consume 20W or more in docked mode. So yes, we can definatly say that Switch will have advantage in terms of efficiency and power consumption compared to real power of hardware.
|
Miyamotoo, we've already discussed the power consumptionthing in another thread, so I'm not going there again. I know it's a lost battle and I have better ways to lose my time.
But what you seem to forget is that the Switch also has to run the game in portable mode, and in that mode it won't be able to use those 20W (far from it), but it will also have to power the screen, leaving even less than half those 20W for games. If you take into consideration that games must run in both modes and that no, lowering the resolution won't magically solve the problem, you'll be better if you start to lower your expectations before you get disappointed.
Please excuse my bad English.
Former gaming PC: i5-4670k@stock (for now), 16Gb RAM 1600 MHz and a GTX 1070
Current gaming PC: R5-7600, 32GB RAM 6000MT/s (CL30) and a RX 9060XT 16GB
Steam / Live / NNID : jonxiquet Add me if you want, but I'm a single player gamer.