By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Neo likely using Zen CPU.

After the Scorpio announcement I think it is using Zen without a doubt. Original rumors pointed to Sony having two CPU's, one would be a slightly modified Jaguar, the other would be a next gen Zen. If they went the Jaguar route they could keep the console arond $399.99, but the system would have thermal limits that could not see it reach 5TFLOPS. On the other hand the Zen would result in a $499.99 price tag, but allow them to hit the full 5.5TFLOPS of the RX480.

At this point it only makes since for Sony to choose the second CPU, and assure they have enough power for 4K/30FPS on all games to match the Scorpio. We know that the 4.2TF set up is right on the edge due to the DF article, so a 5.5TF set up could do it noproblem.



Stop hate, let others live the life they were given. Everyone has their problems, and no one should have to feel ashamed for the way they were born. Be proud of who you are, encourage others to be proud of themselves. Learn, research, absorb everything around you. Nothing is meaningless, a purpose is placed on everything no matter how you perceive it. Discover how to love, and share that love with everything that you encounter. Help make existence a beautiful thing.

Kevyn B Grams
10/03/2010 

KBG29 on PSN&XBL

Around the Network
Pemalite said:
iNathan said:

http://vrworld.com/2016/05/11/amd-confirms-sony-playstation-neo-based-zen-polaris/

"As they article writer explained to a comment of mine, to do that would require a complete redesign of Jaguar since designing for FinFET transistors in very different to designing for planar transistors. If it was a simple node shrink they could easily keep using Jaguar (or its successor, Puma).

But going from planar to FinFET requires a redesign. And does not make sense from either a financial point of view or a technological point of view to redesign an existing CPU and GPU. It makes much more sense to use processors designed for FinFET, ie, Zen and Polaris.

This ends up not only with a much more powerful SoC, but it is cheaper to design that much more powerful SoC than to redesign the Jaguar based SoC as they can piggyback it onto already existing R&D for 14 nm FinFET. Even if AMD and Sony were in great financial situations it would make more sense to do things that way."

1) It doesn't require a complete redesign. It requires a respin and a few minor changes.

2) The cost will be insignificant, majority of the cost will be eaten up by the GPU.

3) We have no idea if it will be using 14nm Finfet. It may be manufacturered at TSMC (Like the current chips) which is 16nm Finfet. (Aka. rebranded 20nm.)

4) AMD has often historically taken older GPU/CPU designs and shrunk them down to smaller processes so they can learn about the new geometry size to improve yields.

5) For the love of God please wait on legitimate information instead of reporting on every single possible rumor please, the only rumor we haven't had is that the Power Supply is going to be powered by mice running on the inside of a wheel.

walsufnir said:
I call bullshit. The Xbox One S also is finfet and has a Jaguar CPU still.
Zen isn't even out yet, is it? Not to mention that this would mean a huge upgrade to the ps4.

This.

However, Zen has taped out and should be pretty much ready for 3rd party designs now... However the Neo chip design likely predates Zen's tapeout.

Neo would likely be using Jaguar or Puma in my opinion, it makes the most sense.

This is the post I was looking for. Thank you, Pemalite.



Watch me stream games and hunt trophies on my Twitch channel!

Check out my Twitch Channel!:

www.twitch.tv/AzurenGames

KBG29 said:
After the Scorpio announcement I think it is using Zen without a doubt. Original rumors pointed to Sony having two CPU's, one would be a slightly modified Jaguar, the other would be a next gen Zen. If they went the Jaguar route they could keep the console arond $399.99, but the system would have thermal limits that could not see it reach 5TFLOPS. On the other hand the Zen would result in a $499.99 price tag, but allow them to hit the full 5.5TFLOPS of the RX480.

At this point it only makes since for Sony to choose the second CPU, and assure they have enough power for 4K/30FPS on all games to match the Scorpio. We know that the 4.2TF set up is right on the edge due to the DF article, so a 5.5TF set up could do it noproblem.

Wouldn't any game that's pushing the PS4's GPU require 7.4Tflops for 4k?

Anyway I hope it's true, make 60Fps a certified option for console gamers.



KBG29 said:
After the Scorpio announcement I think it is using Zen without a doubt. Original rumors pointed to Sony having two CPU's, one would be a slightly modified Jaguar, the other would be a next gen Zen. If they went the Jaguar route they could keep the console arond $399.99, but the system would have thermal limits that could not see it reach 5TFLOPS. On the other hand the Zen would result in a $499.99 price tag, but allow them to hit the full 5.5TFLOPS of the RX480.

At this point it only makes since for Sony to choose the second CPU, and assure they have enough power for 4K/30FPS on all games to match the Scorpio. We know that the 4.2TF set up is right on the edge due to the DF article, so a 5.5TF set up could do it noproblem.

You will be disappointed.

No way it will have Zen because of the release date and no it will have Zen because of costs.

I mean, why would Sony even care to compete with Scorpio? They already won this gen, they didn't win because of power of the system, the Playstation brand is wordlwide and not limited to 2 countries, they have the better games, they have the better controller, they even have more games, their online doesn't suck anymore, they now have 2-factor authorization, they have Gran Turismo.

There is no need to compete with a system that will be released a year later.



walsufnir said:
KBG29 said:
After the Scorpio announcement I think it is using Zen without a doubt. Original rumors pointed to Sony having two CPU's, one would be a slightly modified Jaguar, the other would be a next gen Zen. If they went the Jaguar route they could keep the console arond $399.99, but the system would have thermal limits that could not see it reach 5TFLOPS. On the other hand the Zen would result in a $499.99 price tag, but allow them to hit the full 5.5TFLOPS of the RX480.

At this point it only makes since for Sony to choose the second CPU, and assure they have enough power for 4K/30FPS on all games to match the Scorpio. We know that the 4.2TF set up is right on the edge due to the DF article, so a 5.5TF set up could do it noproblem.

You will be disappointed.

No way it will have Zen because of the release date and no it will have Zen because of costs.

I mean, why would Sony even care to compete with Scorpio? They already won this gen, they didn't win because of power of the system, the Playstation brand is wordlwide and not limited to 2 countries, they have the better games, they have the better controller, they even have more games, their online doesn't suck anymore, they now have 2-factor authorization, they have Gran Turismo.

There is no need to compete with a system that will be released a year later.

Whatever they choose to do I am buying a Neo. I just think that sticking with the Jaguar/4.2TF/8GB RAM is not a great choice after the Scorpio announcement. I feel like the Neo should be a premium device that is geared towards A/V enthusiasts and the absolute core gamers. To me it should be Zen/5.5TF/16GB RAM, and push $499.99 - $599.99. 

I don't think they should be looking to sell the Neo in mass numbers, it should be a pure passion project that they are looking to make profit on, and sell at lower quanitities. For people just looking to play games the PS4 2000 at $249.99 is an awesome, deal, and your average COD/GTA/Madden bro has no need for anything but that.

At any rate like I said, I am buying Neo. I need a 4K device to take advantage of my 4K equipment, and PlayStation is the only product I am interested in. So, for better or worse, I am excited about next week, it is definitly going to be fun.



Stop hate, let others live the life they were given. Everyone has their problems, and no one should have to feel ashamed for the way they were born. Be proud of who you are, encourage others to be proud of themselves. Learn, research, absorb everything around you. Nothing is meaningless, a purpose is placed on everything no matter how you perceive it. Discover how to love, and share that love with everything that you encounter. Help make existence a beautiful thing.

Kevyn B Grams
10/03/2010 

KBG29 on PSN&XBL

Around the Network
KBG29 said:
After the Scorpio announcement I think it is using Zen without a doubt. Original rumors pointed to Sony having two CPU's, one would be a slightly modified Jaguar, the other would be a next gen Zen. If they went the Jaguar route they could keep the console arond $399.99, but the system would have thermal limits that could not see it reach 5TFLOPS. On the other hand the Zen would result in a $499.99 price tag, but allow them to hit the full 5.5TFLOPS of the RX480.

At this point it only makes since for Sony to choose the second CPU, and assure they have enough power for 4K/30FPS on all games to match the Scorpio. We know that the 4.2TF set up is right on the edge due to the DF article, so a 5.5TF set up could do it noproblem.

1) What does the CPU have to do with the GPU's floating point performance?

2) 5.5 Teraflops isn't the "full" theoretical ceiling of the RX 480 either.

3) It's not doing 4k.

4) Flops has no correspondance with resolution.

teigaga said:

Wouldn't any game that's pushing the PS4's GPU require 7.4Tflops for 4k?

Anyway I hope it's true, make 60Fps a certified option for console gamers.

Resolutiuon isn't tied to flops.

KBG29 said:

Whatever they choose to do I am buying a Neo. I just think that sticking with the Jaguar/4.2TF/8GB RAM is not a great choice after the Scorpio announcement.

You pretty much get what you are given in console land.
Remember your console is a cost-sensitive device, you aren't getting high-end PC levels of performance or super-computing levels of performance.

Zen is a big CPU core. - Jaguar/Puma/Other cat cores are small cores which are well suited to cost-sensitive/low-end devices like a console.

KBG29 said:

I feel like the Neo should be a premium device that is geared towards A/V enthusiasts and the absolute core gamers. To me it should be Zen/5.5TF/16GB RAM, and push $499.99 - $599.99.


It likely will be a premium device... But that extra budget will likely be eaten up by the GPU and nothing else, remember it still has the same other costs like the Drives remember.

KBG29 said:

At any rate like I said, I am buying Neo. I need a 4K device to take advantage of my 4K equipment, and PlayStation is the only product I am interested in. So, for better or worse, I am excited about next week, it is definitly going to be fun.


I am afraid you are going to be let down. Neo or Scorpio will not be doing native 4k gaming, they simply do not have the power to do so as the technology currently does not exist that is cheap enough.

You will likely have to deal with a compromised 1440P or 1800P experience but with reconstruction or upscaling for 4k, you will of course still see a benefit over regular 1080P rendering though.

If you wan't the proper 4k gaming experience or better... Then PC is still where it is at and will likely be for the rest of this console generation.



--::{PC Gaming Master Race}::--

Pemalite said:
KBG29 said:
After the Scorpio announcement I think it is using Zen without a doubt. Original rumors pointed to Sony having two CPU's, one would be a slightly modified Jaguar, the other would be a next gen Zen. If they went the Jaguar route they could keep the console arond $399.99, but the system would have thermal limits that could not see it reach 5TFLOPS. On the other hand the Zen would result in a $499.99 price tag, but allow them to hit the full 5.5TFLOPS of the RX480.

At this point it only makes since for Sony to choose the second CPU, and assure they have enough power for 4K/30FPS on all games to match the Scorpio. We know that the 4.2TF set up is right on the edge due to the DF article, so a 5.5TF set up could do it noproblem.

1) What does the CPU have to do with the GPU's floating point performance?

As I understood it, the Jaguar architecture has heat issues, so the best balance they could achieve with it is the rumorex specs we know. According to what I read the Zen tech would be capable of running at higher clocks with lower temps and allow them to push the GPU clock up as well. Since we are talking about an APU the CPU has a direct effect on the GPU.

2) 5.5 Teraflops isn't the "full" theoretical ceiling of the RX 480 either.

True, that was not worded well, there is plenty of room for higher output with overclocking and the sufficient cooling. The source I saw said they would be able to reach the same 5.5TF as the RX 480.

3) It's not doing 4k.

Even if it is what we have seen in the rumors, it is well capable of 4K and 30fps in many games both AAA, and indie. Obviously devs will decide what they want to do with it, but I have no doubt all Nuaghty Dog, Sony Santa Monica, Guerrilla Games, and Polyphony Digital  games will be 4K in the single player portion. 

4) Flops has no correspondance with resolution. 

They are not the say all be all, but when we are talming similar architecture they do hold some wieght.

teigaga said:

Wouldn't any game that's pushing the PS4's GPU require 7.4Tflops for 4k?

Anyway I hope it's true, make 60Fps a certified option for console gamers.

Resolutiuon isn't tied to flops.

KBG29 said:

Whatever they choose to do I am buying a Neo. I just think that sticking with the Jaguar/4.2TF/8GB RAM is not a great choice after the Scorpio announcement.

You pretty much get what you are given in console land.
Remember your console is a cost-sensitive device, you aren't getting high-end PC levels of performance or super-computing levels of performance.

Zen is a big CPU core. - Jaguar/Puma/Other cat cores are small cores which are well suited to cost-sensitive/low-end devices like a console.

We just have to wait and see what Neo ends up being. I feel like they are making a high end A/V devices type of market in the console space. This is a place where you can find $1000+ Blu-Ray Players, and multi-thousand dollar receivers, both of which have much much lower priced entry level devices. So Neo could be anywhere from $399.99 to $999.99, we just have to see.

KBG29 said:

I feel like the Neo should be a premium device that is geared towards A/V enthusiasts and the absolute core gamers. To me it should be Zen/5.5TF/16GB RAM, and push $499.99 - $599.99.


It likely will be a premium device... But that extra budget will likely be eaten up by the GPU and nothing else, remember it still has the same other costs like the Drives remember.

Again, we just have to see. I think the base parts are no more than $140 on the PS4 2000 when you take the APU. So I think they have a ton of room to go with the new APU and additional RAM and still stay in that price range.

KBG29 said:

At any rate like I said, I am buying Neo. I need a 4K device to take advantage of my 4K equipment, and PlayStation is the only product I am interested in. So, for better or worse, I am excited about next week, it is definitly going to be fun.


I am afraid you are going to be let down. Neo or Scorpio will not be doing native 4k gaming, they simply do not have the power to do so as the technology currently does not exist that is cheap enough.

You will likely have to deal with a compromised 1440P or 1800P experience but with reconstruction or upscaling for 4k, you will of course still see a benefit over regular 1080P rendering though.

If you wan't the proper 4k gaming experience or better... Then PC is still where it is at and will likely be for the rest of this console generation.

Whatever they do, I am just happy to see both Sony and Microsoft offering upgraded consoles. I have been wanting this since PS3 came out and Ken talked about the scalability of Cell. 

I think that I will get plenty of 4K content, because I don't expect every game to be 4K/60FPS. I know in the console space the devs have the reins and they will deliver the best experience they feel they can, and they will put it out at whatever resolution and frame rate they think delivers that. So, whether they have a RX 480 or 10 RX 480's you can never be sure you will get that golden zone some people want.

Finally, no offense to people that like PC, but I will never be re-entering that market. I just prefer an optimized and streamlined device and OS.



Stop hate, let others live the life they were given. Everyone has their problems, and no one should have to feel ashamed for the way they were born. Be proud of who you are, encourage others to be proud of themselves. Learn, research, absorb everything around you. Nothing is meaningless, a purpose is placed on everything no matter how you perceive it. Discover how to love, and share that love with everything that you encounter. Help make existence a beautiful thing.

Kevyn B Grams
10/03/2010 

KBG29 on PSN&XBL

Pemalite said:

KBG29 said:

Whatever they choose to do I am buying a Neo. I just think that sticking with the Jaguar/4.2TF/8GB RAM is not a great choice after the Scorpio announcement.

 


Zen is a big CPU core. - Jaguar/Puma/Other cat cores are small cores which are well suited to cost-sensitive/low-end devices like a console.

 

Actually, Zen has very small cores (4.9mm^2 reportedly). That would make a fictional 8core Neo (or even a 6core unit would suffice) feasible inside a Neo SoC. However, all that cache ultimately makes the whole package too big/expensive for a console. Also AMD in its roadmaps for the Zen architecture does not show third party access to the Zen architecture until 2017. The design of the Neo SoC was likely finished in (late?) 2015 so that simply doesn't compute for Zen.

The idea that Sony would have any viable way to change the SoC design "after the Scorpio announcement" is laughable at best. Yes there are tons of rumours (more precisely: fanboy wet dreams) floating around that "Sony has two cpu designs to choose - and after the Scorio announcement blablabla..". Of course Sony had several designs for the cpu. When they started to play with ideas about a Neo. That probably was in 2013/14 when they started seriously thinking about a beefed up PS4. If you are lucky, you can change a key component inside a SoC and you are back where you were after 6-8 months at best.

The next idiotic rumours came up when "4k gaming" was the new buzzword. The Neo is not equipped for 4k gaming. For 4k gaming you do not only need TFlops (Compute Units), you need enough TMUs and ROPs and memory bandwidth. NIVidia's new 10x0 gpu line has 48-64 ROPs (with double raster power), high clock rates and high memory bandwitdh to get into the 4k terrain. The Neo SoC most likely has none of all that. Spicing up the PS4 memory bandwidth to a possible 220GB/s gives you more room for compute usage (good for PSVR use and cpu/gpu sharing of the bus), but by far not enough for "true" 4k gaming.

Why don't people just wait a week or so to see what Sony has to say about the Neo (provided that announcement really opens up the hardware)? Personally I can see a Neo SoC with upclocked Jaguar cores (we know the 14/16nm design was done because of XBox Slim) and a gpu with double the CUs (excellent for gpgpu stuff) and unknown TMU count and same 32 ROPs due to 256 bit memory bus. That would be completely in line with the original 4.2TF rumour.



drkohler said:

Actually, Zen has very small cores (4.9mm^2 reportedly).

Going to need to see the evidence for that one... As I highly doubt it's going to be competitive with AMD's small cat cores.

Jaguar for instance was 3.1mm at 28nm per core, Intel's haswell core that Zen should be doing battle against was 14.5mm at 22nm, if AMD chooses TSMC 20nm rebranded 16nm Finfet... Well. You get the idea, i just don't see Zen having a third of the die size as Haswell.
Intel had a 64% reduction when moving from 22nm to 14nm... And Intel scales it's fabrication better than TSMC.

Remember that Zen is pretty wide (Twice as wide as Jaguar) and had to bolster/duplicate large chunks of the pipeline in order to accomidate AMD's version of Hyper Threading, higher associative cache, better branch prediction and pre-fetcher, Micro-Op cache... And everything seems to be power gated which also costs transisters.

drkohler said:

That would make a fictional 8core Neo (or even a 6core unit would suffice) feasible inside a Neo SoC. However, all that cache ultimately makes the whole package too big/expensive for a console. Also AMD in its roadmaps for the Zen architecture does not show third party access to the Zen architecture until 2017. The design of the Neo SoC was likely finished in (late?) 2015 so that simply doesn't compute for Zen.


Yeah. Zen isn't light on cache, although, AMD will likely do a version without any L3 cache which could drastically reduce the die size, but we still aren't talking Jaguar levels here. :P

drkohler said:

The next idiotic rumours came up when "4k gaming" was the new buzzword. The Neo is not equipped for 4k gaming. For 4k gaming you do not only need TFlops (Compute Units), you need enough TMUs and ROPs and memory bandwidth. NIVidia's new 10x0 gpu line has 48-64 ROPs (with double raster power), high clock rates and high memory bandwitdh to get into the 4k terrain. The Neo SoC most likely has none of all that. Spicing up the PS4 memory bandwidth to a possible 220GB/s gives you more room for compute usage (good for PSVR use and cpu/gpu sharing of the bus), but by far not enough for "true" 4k gaming.

I'm well aware and keep trying to tell people this. Haha

 

drkohler said:

Why don't people just wait a week or so to see what Sony has to say about the Neo (provided that announcement really opens up the hardware)? Personally I can see a Neo SoC with upclocked Jaguar cores (we know the 14/16nm design was done because of XBox Slim) and a gpu with double the CUs (excellent for gpgpu stuff) and unknown TMU count and same 32 ROPs due to 256 bit memory bus. That would be completely in line with the original 4.2TF rumour.

Puma+ is also a feasible alternative to Jaguar.

KBG29 said:

As I understood it, the Jaguar architecture has heat issues, so the best balance they could achieve with it is the rumorex specs we know. According to what I read the Zen tech would be capable of running at higher clocks with lower temps and allow them to push the GPU clock up as well. Since we are talking about an APU the CPU has a direct effect on the GPU.

Jaguar is fine and at 14 or 16nm would have decent power consumption.
It doesn't really affect the GPU's Teraflops though as that is always going to be a theoretical ceiling.

KBG29 said:


True, that was not worded well, there is plenty of room for higher output with overclocking and the sufficient cooling. The source I saw said they would be able to reach the same 5.5TF as the RX 480.


It's not overclocking though.

AMD will bin chips depending on how well they operate at a certain given frequency with a certain level of voltage, some chips require more, some require less and that can influence maximum clock rate if you need to hit a certain TDP.

With aggressive binning you can release a chip with a higher clock speed, on the same fabrication and use less energy.

For example... If Sony was more aggressive with the PS4 binning... They could have made the PS4's APU 20% faster and used 20% less power.

KBG29 said:

Even if it is what we have seen in the rumors, it is well capable of 4K and 30fps in many games both AAA, and indie. Obviously devs will decide what they want to do with it, but I have no doubt all Nuaghty Dog, Sony Santa Monica, Guerrilla Games, and Polyphony Digital  games will be 4K in the single player portion.


It doesn't have the grunt for 4k and 30fps, not with all the settings dialed up anyway, simpler/older and indie games sure.

And do you really only want to play only PS4-levels of graphics and nothing more?

For 4k gaming expectations... You just need to look at Polaris anyway, it's a GPU that is better suited to 1080P and 1440P, no question.

KBG29 said:

They are not the say all be all, but when we are talming similar architecture they do hold some wieght.


But it really doesn't hold any weight.
Flops are calculated as Clock Rate * 2 * Shader count.

So for instance... If you had two GPU's that had 1 Terafaflop of performance, identical amount of shaders, identical clock speed...
But one GPU had 50% more memory bandwidth, 50% more Render Output Units, 50% more Texture Mapping Units, 50% more geometry engines... Then even though they both have the same identical Teraflop ceiling... One will be substnatually faster, in-some cases by 50%.

And this is why you cannot compare the PS4 GPU against the Neo's "theoretical" hardware, because even if the Neo had the same amount of bandwidth on paper... It actually has substantually more.

Plus, even comparing AMD's GPU's on Teraflops alone tends to be inaccurate at best anyway, there are some parts with more flops, that are actually slower than parts with less flops.

KBG29 said:
We just have to wait and see what Neo ends up being. I feel like they are making a high end A/V devices type of market in the console space. This is a place where you can find $1000+ Blu-Ray Players, and multi-thousand dollar receivers, both of which have much much lower priced entry level devices. So Neo could be anywhere from $399.99 to $999.99, we just have to see.

If they can nail it with the Multimedia they could very well indeed be onto a winner, that's for sure.

Microsoft won the multimedia Battle with it's Xbox One Slim console, so it would be fantastic if the Neo was competitive on that front. (The PS4 and Slim certainly aren't.)

KBG29 said:

Again, we just have to see. I think the base parts are no more than $140 on the PS4 2000 when you take the APU. So I think they have a ton of room to go with the new APU and additional RAM and still stay in that price range.


Well. We have no idea what actual hardware the Neo is using just yet. For all we know it could be a derivative of Vega.



--::{PC Gaming Master Race}::--

"As they article writer explained "

Lost all credibility not even 3 words in...