I was disappointed, but I gave it a 5. The Gears 4 demo was good, but whenever a character spoke, the puns that came out were terrible. Since ReCore was coming out so soon, I was hoping for a deeper exploration of that game. I liked the new Xbox S (and price), but Project Scorpio seemed a little premature. I think I hated the Minecraft section the most, second only to the new features being added to the system. I'm not sure what I was expecting, but I can't believe that those three new features were the most requested features for the system. I didn't hate it, but it didn't stand out as particularly good, so a 5 seems fair for an average performance.

It was expected

there is still choice. thee always has been. 

lets stop moving the posts here. This is good for MS, bad for Xbox. The choice used to be between buying a console (PS, XB or nintendo) or a PC. Now, realistically speaking, the choice is down to being between buying a console (PS/nintendo) and a PC. 

Right now, MS has basically told eveeyone that supported Xbox "thanks, it was nice knowing you, bye". What single reason is there to own an Xbox console now?

Don't get me wrong, I'm happy for MS i support MS (typing this on a surface book) and will continue to support them. But this is about Xbox. And as of  today, the xbox brand is officially dead. They very well can just call it windows store gpimg forward and it wouldnt make a difference. 

Oh yeah, xbox is so dead. That's why they announce two new xbox systems. Here is a tip. People in the real world for the most part don't want to game on a pc. That is why PS4 is so popular. Do you think people went out and bought a ps4 for Uncharted and Bloodborne? LOL. 

MS can release or annoucne all the consoles they want. Doesnt mean the xbox brand isnt dead. Just look at windowa phone. That has been dead for 3yrs. Didnt stop them from still trying though.

You don't have to take my word for it. Feel free to believe what you want. Eventually you will see. 

No new game announcements. Every "exclusive" announced is also coming to PC. 90% of the gameplay footage was underwhelming (Gears looked super generic. WTF was going on with FFXV?). An absolute cringefest with Sea of Thieves, Minecraft , and Scalebound gameplay (lol, lemme put on my Beats to fight this monster). 

The best thing they showed was customizable controllers. 

Gave it a 5 out of 10, because 1 would be too harsh, but there was no other option less than 5.

And pretty much all of /r/XboxOne agrees with me (much bigger community than VGC, 211k subs, 4500 active today), so I know I'm not alone or have a "troll" opinion. 

I don't think you understand that what's good for Microsoft, the corporation, isn't necessarily good for Xbox, the brand. Microsoft can do away with that brand. And then they're no more a game company than Apple.

It's at least a solid 7/10 going by the announcements ...

Forza Horizon 3 and Dead Rising 4 reveal stole the show as far as games are concerned but first footage for smaller games is appreciated as well ...

7.5

There is a lot for me to look forward to in the very near future: Gears 4, DR4, HW2, ReCore. Forza Horizon 3 is probably one of the most impressive games I've seen at E3. But all of those amazing trailers were dragged down by ID@Xbox (it's the third year in a row you're there, we know you're cool with the indies by now, + those indie games were previously announced anyway), the Minecraft demo, and some poorly chosen sequence to demo (FFXV, Scalebound). Still, it was a good show overall, maybe a bit weaker than their 2015 one.

Solid 7/10. There's a chance I'll pick up a couple games they showed. The Bioshock-like indie (forgot what it was called) about the happy pills looks really interesting. Sea of thieves looks like it could be a really fun game to mess around on with friends. Scalebound looks like a maybe, but I wasn't very impressed by today's demo, so I'd say I'm less likely to get it now, and same thing goes for FFXV.