1) What IP should Nintendo turn into a movie first?

2) What style should it have? CG? Live-Action? Claymation?

Optional:

3) Who should write/direct?

4) In case of live-action style, who should play the character(s)?

Shoot!

Live action Punch-Out!!

Yup, Punch-Out.

As I said in the other thread Punch-Out!! has SOOO MUCH POTENTIAL, but they need to find the right actors for the key roles. of course it'd need to be a Live Action movie. I don't really know many directors/actors, I'm limited to the main characters of the MCU...

Another combo might be F-Zero, live action directed by Michael Bay but I know that it'd cost too much and that it'd have a 90% chance of beeing terribe

Edit: I don't know how I forgot about this: Matt Groening and the people behind Wreck it Ralph would be pretty amazing as Directors for the more cartoony movies...

Punch-out can become the next rocky balboa.

I just see it going horribly wrong...

One of those I could see being possible is Kid Icarus.

my vote:

Kid Icarus & metroid.

I guess Fire Emblem could work as well.

Stick to games that actually have storylines?

Judging by what Nintendo's president has said live action seems to be a current impossibility because of the last time they did it. So it will be more than likely something like they did with Starfox.

Like i said in the other thread Earthbound made my Pixar

Could you imagine Mike Tyson playing Doc Louis?

An anime Fire Emblem movie.