Well Fallout 3 and Dark Souls 2 was my top 2 favorite games of the 7th gen, so theres that. Nintendo showed nothing new. Sony showed TLG, my hype died for that game a couple of years ago. Im not a FF fan and I really dont get the hype for Horizon.

2014 was around 2 years ago now though and even then I don't really see the other two getting votes this year, what with all the NX talk, MS apparently focussing more and more on PC, it's all set up in a way that they aren't likely to win this year or the enxt, not unless they pull some godsplitter of a move this year and I honestly don't see that happening.

Dunno about NX though, we've had a good number of years of a comfortable Nintendo that's fine with Wii like hardware, the last time they tried to go with power was the Gamecube and that was a long time ago which to their end, didn't produce amazing results for them since PS2 got the lead and was liked more. If they don't screw up with NX then that would be considered a normal thing for them to do (business and consumer wise not sucking should never be looked at like some bonus treat).

Agree on horizon, the game looks good graphical but I'm not sold on the planet of the apes with robots story. TLG demo look really boring like they threw it together real quick to show that the game was actually real and not another trailer.

we're making a retrospect, aren't we ? so what I see is that ReCore, the only game I was interested in in the Microsoft presentation (and that probably I would have prefered to play over any other game shown by any company at E3) has been delayed and we've still not seen actual gameplay.

On the other hand games such as FFVII Remake or No Man Sky have recieved actual gameplay, a release date/period (2017 for FFVII, June for NMS) and expanded on what we knew from E3 (ie. we now know that the battle system in FFVII remake has changed from the original).

Don't get me wrong, there are plenty of games that Microsoft showed that already released or are about to, heck look at Dark Souls III, but out of those that caught my interest I have to say that as of now Sony has won. 

There were no winners. Only losers. Of course, Nintendo lost hardest.

Based on the awards and nominations after E3, I think downplaying Horizon would be a huge mistake. It is clear that it is going to be a huge IP and have an interesting world that innovates on numerous levels. 

I doubt it tbh. Evolve also won awards and nominations remember.

MS had a better *show*, but Sony had better *announcements*. Sony could have had a way better show considering the stuff they showed, but maybe they just thought they'd let the announcements speak for themselves, which I guess they sorta did.

So in the end I'd say Sony.

E3 is about the Megatons.

Sony dropped them in numbers.

Lets hope we can also enjoy this year's E3 without leaks or spoilers.

Definitely not Nintendo lol. I still think Bethesda had the best press conference... it was concise and to the point, and we all got to see several new big titles announced, none bigger than Fallout 4 which was released a mere 5 months later.

Between M$ and Sony, I think they both had equally good press conferences with plenty of titles, but Sony maintained the momentum they had despite the delay of Uncharted 4, so I'd give the edge to them.