Forums - Gaming Discussion - would you ever "10" a game

The Ratchet and Clank series would be the games I'd give the highest rating to. Not a perfect 10, though, but certainly close. Don't ask me why, because I don't have a clue why I'd chose this series over any other, I'm just a huge fan of them.



Around the Network

only three

super mario rpg
mariokart 64
mortal kombat 2 (of course especially after one day i had walked into an arcade with 20 bucks and walked out with 100 hehe, dont ask ;))



dick cheney loves me, he wants to take me hunting

 

mkwii code- 1977-0565-0049

There is no such thing as a perfect game, because gaming is not a static environment. Every games value diminishes with time. Can something that is perfect become less then perfect. A perfect sphere is still a perfect sphere today, tomorrow, and a million years from now. Perfection is permanent and immutable. Perfect is unattainable and is merely an illusion. To claim otherwise is to be blind to the reality of our lives.

That said a 10/10 is merely the best of a generation, and probably a dozen games at most will sit at that position. For me the prime consideration for a rating which is basically a justification for purchase must be title longevity of continuous use. I always run the cost benefit analysis. When a title starts to edge near a quarter per hour of play. I know that despite what others say I have a game that is a 10.

For me these are the titles that would be 10/10. They weren't perfect, but they were worth every cent. Goldeneye, Mario Kart 64, Halo, and Halo 3. Other titles were fantastic, but they never kept me glued to my console for countless weeks and months.



SSBB 10/10!! but if we could go higher it would be over 9000!!!



darklich13 said:
tastyshovelware said:
i guess the only game i would "10" would be 'secret of mana' (great active battle rpg, 2 player action, some of the best graphics/sound on the snes, long adventure)

soul caliber would come the closest.

then RE4.

 You are very wise!


 thank you good sir.

:)



Around the Network

Brawl, RE4 and SMG are really close to ten



Proud owner of a Wii, a Xbox360 and a PS3 (...two PS3's...)


My main brawl characters

Now playing:

wii:Super smash bros. brawl, The Legend Of Zelda: Twilight Princess
ps3: Guitar hero 3,4,5. Rock Band 1,2. Resistance 2
Xbox360:Nhl2k9, Mass Effect, MW2, Halo 3.


I recently "10"d Super Smash Bros. Brawl.. and meant it!

 



Nintendo Fan Girl said:
SSBB 10/10!! but if we could go higher it would be over 9000!!!
You realize what you wrote makes absolutely no sense, right? You're either claiming SSBB is a 9000 out of 9000 which is just another way to word it's a 10 out of 10 or you're implying that SSBB is a 9000 out of 10 which would make it perfect times 900. If the latter's the case this is like trying to one up someone in numbers by yelling "Infinity Plus One!". What are you 16 or something?

 



Tag: Became a freaking mod and a complete douche, coincidentally, at the same time.



Yes I'd 10 a few games. Such as:

LoZ: OOT- 10
LoZ: TP- 10
RE4- 10
SM64- 10

I think those are the only 4's I could give perfect 10s. Those that would come close such as either 9.8 or 9.9 include

Burnout 3
SW: KOTOR
Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem
Super Mario Galaxy
Banjo Kazooie

Yea we'll go with that for now.



Theres no game I'd give a perfect 10. Every game has its annoyances.

CoD4 is amazing but some things such as random grenade throws that kill you, people using the noob tube, people using juggernaut, lag. Stuff like that keeps it from being a perfect 10.