Rise of the Tomb Raider, Halo 5 and Rare Replay.

Oh and Animal Crossing: Amiibo Festival and Mario Tennis Ultra Smash have sold way to much, they deserve to bomb even harder than that.

Rise of the tomb raider. Compared to the sales of the original, this game seriously bombed.

Halo 5. This game seriously under perfomed compared to franchise standards.

Assassins creed. If i remember this didnt do nearly as well as unityband other ac games

Rise of Tomb Raider. For sure!!!!

Most people that bought Rare Replay bought it digital.

Definitely Halo 5. The game is a flop compared to previous Halo games.
RoTR still has a chance to sell decently on the PS4.

MGSV . First week sales is good but then sales drop sharply. I thought it will do at least 5 million on ps4 alone.

Rise of the Tomb Raider or Halo 5.

Of course is Rise of the Tomb Raider, the game was very well rated on Metacritic, and had a Multi-million Fan Base, the Marketing to make the people purchase a Xbox One, did not worked, and who already had a Xbox One, did not supported the game.

it's IMO between tomb raider or halo though I feel tomb raider takes the number #1 position.

I think it's Rise of the Tomb Raider.