But that's only because you are used to a certain paradigm, not that it isn't fitting.

A Zelda game similar to Shovel Knight with more of a Zelda spin would be fantastic.

1. Ocarina of Time
2. The Wind Waker
3. A Link To The Past
4. Majora's Mask
5. Skyward Sword

1: A Link To The Past
2: Ocarina Of Time
3: Majora's Mask
4: Wind Waker
5: Minish Cap / Link's Awakening

1. Ocarina of Time
2. Skyward Sword
3. A Link to the Past
4. Twilight Princess
5. Majora's Mask

I always change my mind, but OoT is at top.

So, looking at the lists, is Skyward Sword probably the most divisive Zelda game to date? I see a sort of love-hate feeling for this game.

That's what I've gotten. Some people absolutely love it, but when I played it I didn't like it that much.

I haven't finished every Zelda as of yet, but based on what i've played:

1.) Skyward Sword
2.) Wind Waker
3.) Twilight Princess
4.) Phantom Hourglass
5.) Ocarina of Time (1st Zelda I ever played)

I swear I've seen like 5 of these favorite LOZ games threads in the past 2 weeks. =)

1.OOT
2. TP
3. ALTP
4. MM
5. SS

In all time worst games I've ever played, WW sits just above ET for the Atarti 2600.

Wait really? XD

Was so let down by WW. The only cool moment was the reveal of Hyrule under the water. The rest was so disappointing for me, too easy. I get it, it was intended for getting school age kids into Zelda, sort of like how Star Wars Episode 1 was doing the same for the series, but still, just didn't mesh with what I enjoy about zelda games.