On my first playthrough I take the path that benefits me the most, even if that means taking the bad karma path. After that, I take the good karma path. And if an easy trophy is at stake, I take the bad karma path too.

Me too.

I take the good guy route, because I'm a goody two-shoes kind of player, haha... The boring kind that is.

Always the good guy .  I am the bane of evil everywhere . 

I try to play it straight down the middle. Which most games like this don't really let you do in the long run. Though I find that makes game endings really gripping. I'm so undecided about my character's morality that it makes my choices more compelling.

KOTOR was the longest I got with this. Up until the very, very last mission I was neither good nor evil.

Fallout 3 I didn't like as much because it forced my hand too early.

Both, it just has to be.

Good guy first, bad guy 2nd.

Always good. Bad is too easy, and if I don't like to hurt people in real life I don't like to pretend that I'm doing it in a game. Part of the fun is immersing myself in the world and having the power I don't have in real life, so I like to make decisions based on what I would do myself in those situations. (Which is mostly good, but not necessarily always good.)

Good guy first, then bad guy.

I know I'm siding Hoshido over Nohr in FE: Fates, for example.

Good karma at first, then bad for second playthrough. Though this was for inFamous 1 & 2; for inFamous Second Son I only beat it as a good guy.